I was just watching the Denver/Atlanta game recap and saw this happen and I remember seeing it happen in one other game this year and it makes no sense to me.
Atlanta committed a penalty for illegal shift, but for some reason it's not blown dead, they complete a pass and the receiver then gets facemasked. The illegal shift penalty is disregarded and the offense gets a free 15 yds. If its not blown dead then that means its a free play for the defense not a free play for offense. So how does the offense get to benefit after their penalty?
I dont understand how the illegal shift isn't blown dead like false start is. This game was a blowout so it didnt matter, but I'm pretty sure the other time I saw it happen this year it was a more impactful play. Regardless it makes no sense to me.
0
To remove first post, remove entire topic.
I was just watching the Denver/Atlanta game recap and saw this happen and I remember seeing it happen in one other game this year and it makes no sense to me.
Atlanta committed a penalty for illegal shift, but for some reason it's not blown dead, they complete a pass and the receiver then gets facemasked. The illegal shift penalty is disregarded and the offense gets a free 15 yds. If its not blown dead then that means its a free play for the defense not a free play for offense. So how does the offense get to benefit after their penalty?
I dont understand how the illegal shift isn't blown dead like false start is. This game was a blowout so it didnt matter, but I'm pretty sure the other time I saw it happen this year it was a more impactful play. Regardless it makes no sense to me.
Once they snap it and its a penalty though, its a free play for the defense. The offense cant gain yards unless the defense declines the penalty. So i dont think the defense should be penalized on their own free play. Maybe I'm crazy but it seems wacky
0
@TJZags598
Once they snap it and its a penalty though, its a free play for the defense. The offense cant gain yards unless the defense declines the penalty. So i dont think the defense should be penalized on their own free play. Maybe I'm crazy but it seems wacky
If the defense just off sides, but the offense commits a 15 yard penalty ( unsportsmanlike like) the 5 yard penalty for offsides is wiped out.
Just as the offense can take a risk ( throw the ball long ) when the defense jumps offsides....The defense can now go for an interception, or sack, and take more risk.
The offense definitely has the advantage though
0
Keep in mind it works both way
If the defense just off sides, but the offense commits a 15 yard penalty ( unsportsmanlike like) the 5 yard penalty for offsides is wiped out.
Just as the offense can take a risk ( throw the ball long ) when the defense jumps offsides....The defense can now go for an interception, or sack, and take more risk.
In the NFL, why does a personal foul that happens after the result of the play erase the play completely? For example a quarterback throws an interception and then gets roughed after the throw has been made. Why would the result of the play not stand and the penalty apply to the next offensive possession? After all, if a QB throws an interception, nothing that happens after the fact changes the fact that the QB threw the interception.
0
@TJZags598
Here’s one for you TJ-
In the NFL, why does a personal foul that happens after the result of the play erase the play completely? For example a quarterback throws an interception and then gets roughed after the throw has been made. Why would the result of the play not stand and the penalty apply to the next offensive possession? After all, if a QB throws an interception, nothing that happens after the fact changes the fact that the QB threw the interception.
If you choose to make use of any information on this website including online sports betting services from any websites that may be featured on
this website, we strongly recommend that you carefully check your local laws before doing so.It is your sole responsibility to understand your local laws and observe them strictly.Covers does not provide
any advice or guidance as to the legality of online sports betting or other online gambling activities within your jurisdiction and you are responsible for complying with laws that are applicable to you in
your relevant locality.Covers disclaims all liability associated with your use of this website and use of any information contained on it.As a condition of using this website, you agree to hold the owner
of this website harmless from any claims arising from your use of any services on any third party website that may be featured by Covers.