Quote Originally Posted by porcelainfist:
Philly, thank you for posting this. You're one of my favorite cappers here.
However, I disagree with almost every side here. I do like Car, even if it's chalky, as long as it stays at -3 I don't see what the Broncs lovers are seeing.
That's funny, because Carolina is actually the side I was least confident in, and I am now actually making this a NO PLAY for several reasons (maybe this will help you see what people like about Denver as a play)
Firstly, the Super Bowl loser has generally struggled ATS the following year. Conversely, the Super Bowl winner who in recent years has always been scheduled to play the first game at home (though the Ravens had to play on the road one year) in a night TV game like MNF or now TNF, they have usually won those games. I haven't looked back at the actual W-L record but if my memory serves correct they have usually won. And I don't think they've ever been an underdog. So to me the line value is not there, and now the juice is high too so it's just crappy value overall.
Also in looking at the line, despite the news that the Broncos are going to start a rookie, the line hasn't moved at all. While books are loathe to move off a critical number like 3, this is still surprising. When you compare to two other teams who are in the exact same situation where they have just decided at the last minute to start rookies - Dallas and Philadelphia, the line dropped, in Dallas' case it swung 4 points even though Prescott had a great preseason. To me that's surprising considering those teams opponents are the Browns and Giants, both teams that I feel are the epitome of mediocrity. The fact that the Broncos line hasn't gone up means there's still plenty of Denver money out there, especially considering this is the first game of the year and on TV ie: a heavily bet game.
Siemian's Northwestern team was similar to the Broncos in a lot of ways, they played tough D, ran the ball and ground out ugly wins. They performed well in underdog roles and the fact that the team have handed him the reigns means he must be doing okay in practice (playing against the Denver D would be a good yardstick), and being a smart Northwestern guy he probably didn't have trouble with the more complex NFL playbook. And anyway, the Broncos didn't win with offense for most of the year last year.
The Panthers haven't really upgraded their team and they lost one of their catalysts on defense. Denver lost some important guys but they got Miller signed and they still have TJ Ward on the back end. I was surprised that the Panthers offense played so well last year despite their lack of WRs and I don't seem them lighting up the Broncos through the air.
Carolina was a beaten favorite on a neutral field, now they're favored again on the road? I dunno, I think they had a great year last year, it came to a screeching halt and I don't know if they're going to be anywhere near as good this year. The year before remember, people were complaining about them even being in the playoffs when they only went 8-8 in the worst division in the NFL.
Mile High is always a tough place to play and while I still lean to the Panthers, my final reason for not betting it is simply this: while a younger Philly was chomping at the bit to bet the first game of the year and loved playing the TV games, older Philly now likes to just sit back and watch some games for their entertainment value. I'm playing more games than usual this Sunday, so tonight I'm just going to crack some brews and enjoy this one. There will be plenty more games to bet, but to get a Super Bowl rematch as the first game is just the perfect situation to chill out and enjoy it. Might take some small prop bets for entertainment purposes but not going to bother risking anything significant, just gonna watch as a football fan.