- He will be in top 10 but I doubt he will make the top 5. Anyway that is just my opinion.
They play the best as a team but as individuals they fall short. Only have to look at Dane Swan and the brownlow medal over the years. It's coming down to either Goodes, Murphy, Mitchell or Ablett.You are kidding right? There is no way a guy who played in 3 winning games and the rest floggings will score enough votes to even come top 5, let alone have a chance at winning. 
Maybe
Agreed - it will be close between him Reddan and Black. There will only be 1 or 2 votes in it. The problem is Black scores votes regardless - he has that history.
Agreed
Nah.
If someone edges one of these players; Judd, Goodes, Swan, Pendlebury, Boyd, Murphy out of the top 5, it will be Dean Cox or Scott Thompson. I don't have a phantom count in front of me but Adelaide won 7 games and in most those games Thompson was the better player. 18 votes is the minimum you will need to get top 5. Cox could poll a lot too. Umpires seem to love him.
You are kidding right? There is no way a guy who played in 3 winning games and the rest floggings will score enough votes to even come top 5, let alone have a chance at winning.
Established in 1995,
Hot Forum Topics
