Jayson Tatum Picks, Predictions & Best Bets for Knicks vs Celtics Game 2

Our Jayson Tatum picks don't think his Game 1 rebounding effort will carry over into Game 2.

Jason Logan: Senior Betting Analyst at Covers
Jason Logan • Senior Betting Analyst
May 7, 2025 • 12:41 ET • 4 min read
Jayson Tatum Boston Celtics NBA
Photo By - Imagn Images. Jayson Tatum of the Boston Celtics takes the court.

Jayson Tatum’s two-faced performance in Game 1 versus the New York Knicks has me drawing connections to Marvel Studios’ newest overpowered character.

(Warning: Thunderbolts* spoilers ahead)

The latest film from the superhero studio introduces us to “Sentry”, a genetically engineered Superman knockoff who also has a dark and disturbed alter-ego, “The Void”.

And that’s what Tatum’s second-half efforts left in the Boston Celtics’ offense on Monday night... a void.  After putting up 13 points in the first 24 minutes, the Celtics superstar would contribute just eight more points and shoot 2-for-11 from the field, sucking all life out of a Boston attack that mustered only 39 points in the second half.

The Celtics would blow a 16-point cushion at the break and eventually lose 108-105 in overtime, leaving fingers pointing at Tatum. Which hero shows up for Game 2? Here are my NBA picks for Knicks vs. Celtics on May 7.

Jayson Tatum player prop picks

  • Best bet
    Tatum Under 9.5 rebounds
    (-110)

  • SGP pick
    Tatum Under 9.5 rebounds
    Holiday Over 3.5 assists
    Celtics team total Over 110.5
    (+475)

Click on each pick to jump to the full analysis.

Jayson Tatum best bet

Jayson Tatum Under 9.5 rebounds (-110 at bet365)

Jayson Tatum tied his season high with 16 rebounds in the Game 1 collapse to New York on Monday. That stat line had a few factors playing into it that won’t be there in Game 2. 

For one, the Boston Celtics straight up sucked in the second half. Boston jumped out to a big lead at the halftime break, then didn’t leave the locker room. The team that did come out for the final 24 minutes fired up a “Sandy Lyle-like” 29% from the floor, including a 9-for-34 brickyard from beyond the arc. A surplus of misses panned out to a surge in rebounding chances, with Tatum drawing 16 of those opportunities on the glass.

Second, Kristaps Porzingis played just 13 minutes due to illness. Boston’s 7-foot unicorn is a very effective rebounder (he did have four rebounds in that limited time), but was barely there on the boards in Game 1. That left Tatum to crash the glass, especially when Boston went with a smaller lineup.

Now, there’s no doubt that Tatum’s rebounding efforts have been beefed up in the postseason (averaged 8.7 in the regular season), with the superstar forward averaging more than 11 rebounds against Orlando in Round 1, but the Magic sold out on stopping the Celtics’ 3-point threats, were undersized in the front court, and were a miserable shooting team themselves (42%). Tatum averaged 17.8 rebounding chances per game for the series.

I expect both the Celtics and Knicks to shoot the ball more consistently in Game 2, leaving fewer misses and rebounds up for grabs. Porzingis is also expected to play more tonight, bumping Tatum to the perimeter and away from the rim.

Before Game 1’s result, Tatum had recorded four, six, seven, and 10 rebounds in the four regular-season clashes with New York, while averaging only 10.3 rebounding chances over those meetings.

Monday’s 16-rebound effort has puffed up Tatum’s prop total for Game 2. It sits at 9.5 with the Over juiced to -129 at some shops. That’s a much bigger ask on the glass than Tatum’s rebound totals to start the playoffs, with those numbers as low as 7.5 O/U.

Player projections range from 8.7 to 9.2 rebounds for the Celtics’ franchise player, but every forecast comes in below the 9.5-rebound bar. My number is at nine rebounds, but the floor feels lower considering those missing factors in Game 2.

Jayson Tatum same-game parlay

Jayson Tatum Under 9.5 rebounds

Jrue Holiday Over 3.5 assists

Celtics team total Over 110.5

Tatum will be out to fix his shot, and with Boston expected to bounce back, there won’t be as many misses to track down for rebounds.

Holiday had plenty of nice passes in Game 1, but Boston couldn’t cash in on those set-ups. I like him to have four or more dimes tonight.

The Celtics’ second-half belly flop burned what looked like a surefire team total Over in Game 1 after scoring 61 first-half points. Boston gets its groove back and scores 111 or more.

Learn how to bet a same-game parlay with these helpful tips and strategies.

Cash your ML bets quicker with bet365's early win payout

Take advantage of the early win payout at bet365, where any pre-game NBA moneyline bet gets paid out as a winner if your team goes up by 20+ points!

Learn more about this feature, and all of bet365's offerings, with our comprehensive bet365 review.

21+. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.

Not intended for use in MA.
Affiliate Disclosure: Our team of experts has thoroughly researched and handpicked each product that appears on our website. We may receive compensation if you sign up through our links.

Pages related to this topic

Jason Logan Senior Industry Analyst Covers.com
Senior Betting Analyst

In his 20 years with Covers, lead NFL betting analyst “JLo” has seen it all and bet it all. Through the wild west of early Internet gambling to lobbying for legalized sports betting to our brave new wagering world, Jason has been a consistent source of actionable info and entertainment for squares and sharps alike.

Since joining the Covers team back in 2005, he’s honed his handicapping skills to provide audiences with the most thorough insights, blending traditional capping methods with advanced modelling and predictive analysis. Jason has studied the ins and outs of the sports betting business, learning from some of the most successful gamblers in the industry and the biggest sportsbook operators on the planet.

He is under center for Covers during NFL season as our top NFL expert, taking the points in his infamous “NFL Underdogs” column and representing the Covers Community at the Super Bowl. While he lives for football season, Jason’s first love is basketball and that shows in his in-depth NBA, NCAA, and WNBA betting breakdowns.

On top of being a mainstay in media from coast to coast – WPIX, PHL17, Fox 5 San Diego, WGNO, TSN, SportsNet, ESPN Radio – he’s had his analysis featured in USA Today, MSNBC, ESPN, the Wall Street Journal, CBS, Bloomberg, the L.A. Times, the New York Times and other major publications. You can also find JLo stuffing all the top picks and predictions he can into 10 minutes as the host of Covers’ flagship podcast, The Sharp 600.

His best advice for bettors new and old is “Handicapping isn’t a ‘one size fits all’ process. The impact and importance of information varies from bet to bet. Treat each wager different than the last.”

Popular Content

Covers is verified safe by: Evalon Logo GPWA Logo GDPR Logo GeoTrust Logo Evalon Logo