Panthers vs Colts Preseason Picks and Predictions: Tension Between Carolina and Indy Comes to a Head

After scrappy joint practices this week, the Panthers and Colts will clash in their preseason opener in Indianapolis. Check out our picks and predictions to see where the NFL betting value is without QBs Sam Darnold and Carson Wentz taking part.

Alistair Corp - Publishing Editor at Covers.com
Alistair Corp • Publishing Editor
Aug 14, 2021 • 16:55 ET • 4 min read
P.J. Walker Carolina Panthers NFL
Photo By - USA TODAY Sports

Two days of tense joint practices will culminate in preseason football for the Carolina Panthers and Indianapolis Colts, as the two teams meet to kickoff their August football schedule on Sunday afternoon.

Both teams will be eager to end their brief marriage with a win after scuffle-filled practices, but neither will be able to rely on the big names to do so. Carolina fans will wait a little longer to get their first look at new quarterback Sam Darnold, with Panthers starters sitting out, while Indianapolis' supporters endure another August of signal-caller uncertainty. 

Will Indy cover a 1.5-point spread as the NFL betting favorites? Read on for our Panthers vs. Colts picks and predictions for August 15.

Panthers vs Colts game info

Location: Lucas Oil Stadium, Indianapolis, IN
Date: Sunday, August 15, 2021
Time: 1:00 p.m. ET
TV: NFL Network

Panthers vs Colts odds

Odds via the Covers Line, an average comprised of odds from multiple sportsbooks.

Compare NFL odds before betting to ensure you get the best number.

Check out the full line movement for this game

Panthers vs Colts betting preview

Weather

Be sure to monitor the gametime conditions with our NFL weather info.

Key injuries

Panthers: Sam Darnold QB (Out), Christian McCaffrey RB (Out), Matt Paradis C (Out), DJ Moore WR (Out), Robby Anderson WR (Out), Brian Burns EDGE (Out).
Colts: Carson Wentz QB (Out), Dayo Odeyingbo DE (Out), Eric Fisher OT (Out), JJ Nelson WR (Out), Rob Windsor DT (Out).
Find our latest NFL injury reports.

Betting trend to know

The Panthers are 8-2 ATS in their last 10 games as an underdog. Find more NFL betting trends for Panthers vs. Colts.

Against the spread (ATS) pick

Fight-filled practices between Indianapolis and Carolina this week will get the chance to be settled as the two meet, though both teams will be heavily depleted. Panthers head coach Matt Rhule has already ruled out the majority of his starters, while the Colts are sure to have a quick hook on the starters they send out. 

Without Darnold or Carson Wentz in this one, we're absent any veterans at quarterback, with Carolina's Will Grier and his 52 career attempts the most experienced passer of the remaining bunch. It's the Panthers' other quarterback, however, that moves the needle.

P.J. Walker, who turned a charmed spell in the XFL into a job backing up Teddy Bridgewater last season — and started one game, throwing for 258 yards and a score with two picks in a win — will start for the Panthers here. Preseason football is a great platform for a QB like Walker, who can push the ball downfield and has the velocity to punish miscommunication in the secondary — a common occurrence in August — as well as pull it and escape the pocket when pressured. Walker has a few strong preseason games already under his belt and should add to that in 2021.

Countering Walker as Indianpolis' starter is second-year passer Jacob Eason. While Eason getting the first reps is a good opportunity for the sophomore QB, in some respects, it's a tough break. Eason's strengths — his raw physical tools and high-level arm strength — would be better served against Carolina's deep reserves. His inability to go through progressions or read a defense, meanwhile, will be amplified against however many starters the Panthers send out.

Rookie Sam Ehlinger has been turning heads in Colts camp and is expected to come in before the first half is finished, but the gap in quality between Walker and the rest of the quarterbacks in this one is massive. A hostile week between the Colts and Panthers ends with Carolina covering against the home favorites. 

PREDICTION: Panthers +1.5 (-107)

Covers NFL betting analysis

Over/Under pick

One of the lowest totals of Week 1 of the preseason will be tested by Indianapolis and Carolina's second- and third-stringers on Sunday, with Rhule announcing his starters won't play while Carson Wentz remains sidelined for the Colts. 

Walker's fit in preseason football has already been touched upon, and the number of drives he receives here will have implications on the total as he will show off genuine playmaking ability. Beyond that, however, it's bleak. 

Replacing Walker will be another willing deep-ball passer in Will Grier, who made a pair of ugly starts in 2019 for Carolina and has not appeared in a regular season game since. If nothing else, Grier has the experience under center to avoid looking completely lost, but his arm talent is lacking even against preseason competition. Granted, his initial preseason came as a rookie two years ago, but Grier was awful in his previous August schedule, completing just over 50 percent of his passes with a grisly 6.3 yards per attempt. 

It's unlikely to be much better for the home side, with the sophomore Eason to be followed by former Longhorn Sam Ehlinger. While Eason relies on intriguing physical traits, Ehlinger is the opposite. He won't blow the roof of Carolina's secondary, nor threaten to, but he should be able to methodically put together a few drives, especially as the Panthers' bench gets thinner and thinner. 

Both teams will get their first live look at a handful of intriguing playmakers down the depth chart. For the Colts, that's second-year wideout Dezmon Patmon and rookie Michael Strachan, both of whom have great size and combine it with elite explosiveness (both tested above the 85th percentile in the broad jump). Patmon and Strachan have both turned heads regularly since the spring, as Indy looks to round out its wide receiver corps. Panthers UDFA CJ Saunders, meanwhile, has been impressing in a crowded receiver group in Carolina. 

Aiding the Under effort, however, is that both teams will bring deep backfields into the preseason and we should see a healthy dose of carries on either side. Plus, while the Colts and Panthers boast creative coaching staffs on offense, both will be content to keep things vanilla as the preseason gets underway. 

Walker is a playmaker who will succeed against the level of competition he'll face Sunday, but there's little reason to anticipate successful days on offense for either team beyond that. Take the Under.

PREDICTION: Under 34 (+101)

Panthers vs Colts betting card

  • Panthers +1.5 (-107)
  • Under 34 (+101)

Picks made on 8/14/2021 at 4:30 p.m. ET

NFL parlays

Did you know that if you parlayed this week’s NFL Panthers vs. Colts picks, you could win $28.89 on a $10 bet?

Use our NFL parlay calculator to create your own parlays and see their potential payouts.

Where can I bet on the NFL?

You can bet on NFL odds at every online and casino sportsbook, including NFL moneylines, spreads, Over/Under totals, and a ton of NFL prop odds. Head over to our best-suggested sportsbooks for the top spots to bet on NFL odds in your area.

Pages related to this topic

Alistair Corp Publishing Editor at Covers.com
Publishing Editor

Alistair has been working as a publishing editor on the Covers content team since January 2021. In addition to his work as an editor, he helps cover the NFL, the NBA, Formula 1, and soccer. Prior to joining Covers, he worked as a freelance writer covering the NFL.

Popular Content

Legal Canadian sports betting

Best Canadian betting sites Ontario sports betting
Covers is verified safe by: Evalon Logo GPWA Logo GDPR Logo GeoTrust Logo Evalon Logo