Live Super Bowl Party Prop Results: Outcomes for MVP, Total Points, Gatorade Color & More

The Chiefs and Eagles aren't the only ones competing for eternal glory at Super Bowl 59. You can also emerge a big winner by correctly predicting the outcome of every item on your party prop sheet. Keep this blog bookmarked during the big game as we reveal the outcome of every major game and broadcast prop throughout the night.

Ryan Murphy Managing Editor at Covers
Ryan Murphy • Managing Editor
Feb 9, 2025

Kansas City Chiefs quarterback Patrick Mahomes (15) points to tight end Travis Kelce (87) after a play.

Live Updates (18)

11 hours ago • 22:28 ET
Ryan Murphy Managing Editor at Covers
Ryan Murphy • Managing Editor

Updated Party Prop Sheet Tally

1. Length of National Anthem: Over 120.5
2. Coin toss: Tails
3. First offensive play: Run
4. First team to score: Eagles
5. First turnover: Interception
6. First accepted penalty: Eagles
7: First team to 10 points: Eagles
8. Will either team score during the final 2 minutes of the first half: Yes (Eagles)
9. First song performed at the Halftime Show: Squabble Up
10. Number of songs played during the Halftime Show: Over 10.5
11. Total number of players to attempt a pass: Over 2.5
12. Player with more passing yards: Patrick Mahomes
13. Player with more rushing yards: Other (Jalen Hurts)
14. Player with more receiving yards: Xavier Worthy
15. Gatorade Color: Lime/Green/Yellow
16. Will either team score during the final 2 minutes of the second half: Yes (Chiefs)
17. Winning team: Eagles
18. Will the game go Over 49.5: Yes (62)
19. Super Bowl MVP: Other (Jalen Hurts)

11 hours ago • 22:23 ET
Ryan Murphy Managing Editor at Covers
Ryan Murphy • Managing Editor

Mahomes Tops Hurts in Passing Yards

It may seem surprising given the final score, but Patrick Mahomes actually had more passing yards than his MVP-cohort Jalen Hurts. The Chiefs QB finished with 257 yards compared to Hurts, who tallied 221. 

11 hours ago • 22:14 ET
Ryan Murphy Managing Editor at Covers
Ryan Murphy • Managing Editor

Total Number of Players to Attempt a Pass: Over 2.5

Eagles backup QB Kenny Pickett only attempted one pass this evening, but it was enough to push this prop to Over 2.5. Take a bow, Kenny, you're a Super Bowl champion.

11 hours ago • 22:09 ET
Ryan Murphy Managing Editor at Covers
Ryan Murphy • Managing Editor

Eagles Dump Lime/Green/Yellow Gatorade on Nick Sirianni

It was deja vu all over this evening as the Eagles dumped Yellow/Green/Lime Gatorade on Nick Sirianni. It was the same color combination the team used following their NFC Championship route of the Washington Commanders. Philly also had the same color on the sidelines at Super Bowl 57.

11 hours ago • 22:07 ET
Ryan Murphy Managing Editor at Covers
Ryan Murphy • Managing Editor

Super Bowl 59 Goes Over 49.5 Points

It was too little, too late, but DeAndre Hopkins' touchdown reception with 2:54 remaining in the fourth quarter ensured Super Bowl 59 would go Over 49.5 points. Cash those tickets Over bettors!

11 hours ago • 21:37 ET
Ryan Murphy Managing Editor at Covers
Ryan Murphy • Managing Editor

Hurts a Prohibitive Favorite for Super Bowl MVP

Jalen Hurts may be just 6-foot-1, but he's head-and-shoulders above the pack when it comes to Super Bowl MVP odds. The Philly QB's odds have improved from +375 when the game began to -2300 late in the fourth quarter as the Eagles have taken a commanding 37-6 lead.

Stick around until the end of the game as we reveal the MVP winner as well as eight other party sheet prop outcomes. 

12 hours ago • 20:43 ET
Ryan Murphy Managing Editor at Covers
Ryan Murphy • Managing Editor

Kendrick Lamar Hits the Over in Songs Played

Kendrick Lamar didn't hold anything back during an epic Super Bowl Halftime Show set that featured Over 10.5 songs and included special cameos by SZA, Samuel L. Jackson, Serena Williams, and DJ Mustard. 

Lamar led off with "Squabble Up" and closed with his mega crowd pleaser, "tv off."

Your move, Drake.

13 hours ago • 20:09 ET
Ryan Murphy Managing Editor at Covers
Ryan Murphy • Managing Editor

Eagles Score During the Last 2 Minutes

Jalen Hurts connects with A.J. Brown for a 12-yard touchdown. The Eagles are now up 24-0 heading into halftime. Not even the most cynical of oddsmakers imagined the defending champs facing a scenario like this.

13 hours ago • 19:39 ET
Ryan Murphy Managing Editor at Covers
Ryan Murphy • Managing Editor

Eagles First to 10 Points

The Eagles now have a two-score lead following Jake Elliott's successful 48-yard field goal. The try was made even harder following a five-yard penalty against Philly. 

13 hours ago • 19:31 ET
Ryan Murphy Managing Editor at Covers
Ryan Murphy • Managing Editor

First Turnover: Interception

Jalen Hurts' pass intended for A.J. Brown is picked off by Bryan Cook at the Kansas City 2-yard line. Cook runs out of bounds for no gain, but the damage has been done.

14 hours ago • 19:06 ET
Ryan Murphy Managing Editor at Covers
Ryan Murphy • Managing Editor

Eagles Score First

The Eagles are on the board! Jalen Hurts finds his way into the end zone thanks to a Philly tush push at the 1-yard line. Jake "The Make" Elliott's extra point is good, putting the Eagles up 7-0.

14 hours ago • 18:50 ET
Ryan Murphy Managing Editor at Covers
Ryan Murphy • Managing Editor

First Game Penalty: Eagles

The Eagles have another first in Super Bowl 59 after committing the game's first penalty. A.J. Brown is called for offensive pass interference, resulting in a 10 yard penalty, enforced at 50.

14 hours ago • 18:46 ET
Ryan Murphy Managing Editor at Covers
Ryan Murphy • Managing Editor

First Offensive Play: Run

The Eagles are off and running! The first play of Super Bowl 59 is a four-yard run by All-Pro running back Saquon Barkley.

Barkley's first quarter rushing total was set at 27.5 yards coming into the game.

14 hours ago • 18:40 ET
Ryan Murphy Managing Editor at Covers
Ryan Murphy • Managing Editor

Tails Never Fails

There's still four quarters to play, but we already have our first big winner: Tails! 

Tails has now been the winner in two of the last three Super Bowls played.

14 hours ago • 18:34 ET
Ryan Murphy Managing Editor at Covers
Ryan Murphy • Managing Editor

Jon Batiste Goes Over in Dazzling National Anthem

Jon Batiste delivered a spectacular performance of the national anthem that we clocked at 125 seconds, considerably Over the opening projection of 120.5 seconds. That final national anthem length surprised many considering the Grammy Award-winner previously delivered much shorter renditions of the Star Spangled Banner at the U.S. Open and the NBA All-Star Game.

15 hours ago • 18:27 ET
Ryan Murphy Managing Editor at Covers
Ryan Murphy • Managing Editor

Will the National Anthem Go Over or Under?

Academy and Grammy Award-winning singer and songwriter Jon Batiste will perform the national anthem at the Super Bowl. The Over/Under time for the Super Bowl national anthem remains at 120.5, but the Under has been steamed to -139.

15 hours ago • 18:24 ET
Ryan Murphy Managing Editor at Covers
Ryan Murphy • Managing Editor

Coin Toss is Coming Soon

Unlike many of the Super Bowl props available, wagering on the coin toss requires zero strategy or knowledge of the game. It's a 50-50 proposition in the truest sense, and that's one of the things that makes it so appealing to causal bettors.

For those that are swayed by trends, it's worth noting that tails has won in three of the last four Super Bowls. Curiously, the winner of the coin toss has won just 44.8% of the past 58 NFL championship games. 

15 hours ago • 17:34 ET
Ryan Murphy Managing Editor at Covers
Ryan Murphy • Managing Editor

Super Bowl Prop Bet Sheet

Our free printable Super Bowl prop bet sheet is now available for your Big Game watch party as the Chiefs clash with the Eagles in New Orleans.

Our sheet features 20 of the most popular betting markets available and offers two or more selections for each wager. All you have to do is make a single selection for each bet and then see how many you correctly predicted after the game has concluded.

Print it, fill it out, and follow along here and on X @Covers for instant prop sheet results during the game!

Download our printable prop bet sheet now!

Pages related to this topic