Today’s NHL Prop Picks and Best Bets: No Points For You

It's another stacked NHL slate on Thursday with 13 games to choose from and our NHL player props are fading two players who appear outmatched in their respective games. In addition, we have a rare goalie prop we are targeting in the desert.

Neil Parker - Analyst at Covers.com
Neil Parker • Betting Analyst
Jan 4, 2024 • 11:00 ET • 4 min read
Tomas Hertl San Jose Sharks NHL
Photo By - USA TODAY Sports

It’s a competitive night on the ice Thursday, and just four of the 13 games feature a huge favorite in the NHL odds.

A Central Division clash between the Colorado Avalanche and Dallas Stars is a potential postseason matchup this spring, while last year’s finalists will meet for the second time this season. The Florida Panthers beat the Vegas Golden Knights before the holiday break, so the matchup between favorites in the Stanley Cup odds checks out as one of the marquee matchups on the slate.

Add in a bout between the Pittsburgh Penguins and Boston Bruins from the early games, and it’s another loaded slate.

Here are our free NHL picks and best NHL player props for Thursday, January 4.

NHL prop picks and best bets for January 4

Picks made on January 4 at 1:30 p.m. ET.
Read full analysis of each pick.

Bet on the NHL at Bet99!

Sign Up Offer
One of Canada's best sportsbooks for NHL betting, join Bet99 and get a 100% match on your first deposit of up to $1,000 when using Bet99 promo code COVERSBONUS!

Today’s NHL prop picks and best bets

Prop bet #1: Rangers say no to Foligno

The Chicago Blackhawks are in for a tough road game against the New York Rangers on Thursday. New York is coming off a 6-1 loss to the Carolina Hurricanes on Tuesday, and I’m expecting the veteran Rangers lineup to tidy it up and wash the inferior Blackhawks.

In particular, I don’t expect Chicago winger Nick Foligno to mark the scoresheet. He has a respectable eight goals and seven assists through 37 games, but his five multi-point showings account for 12 of those 17 points.

He’s missed the scoresheet entirely 27 times (73%).

Aside from skating with the No. 1 power-play unit, Foligno is playing a defensive role with 58.6% of his five-on-five zone starts in his own end. Add the veteran’s 44.3 Corsi For percentage at 5-on-5 and penalty-kill role, and there aren’t many offensive opportunities. The Rangers also rank sixth in penalty-kill percentage (83.6%) to mitigate Foligno’s PP gig.

I believe we’re receiving value on the Nick Foligno odds in this market because most depth charts position Foligno and linemates Jason Dickinson and Colin Blackwell as Chicago’s No. 2 line, but the trio checks out as a fourth line on nearly every other team in the NHL.

Returning to the Blueshirts, No. 1 goalie Igor Shesterkin posted a .946 save percentage across five consecutive wins before Tuesday’s blunder. I’m anticipating a return to Vezina form with the Blackhawks failing to drive possession (43.9 CF%) or generate offense (league-low 2.15 expected goals per 60 minutes) at five-on-five.

Nick Foligno prop: Under 0.5 points (-135 at Bet99)

Prop bet #2: Winnipeg too high a hurdle for Tomas

The Winnipeg Jets have been a nightmare for opposing offenses, and San Jose Sharks center Tomas Hertl has cooled considerably since mid-December.

Winnipeg has allowed the fewest five-on-five goals (1.69) per 60 minutes, and No. 1 goalie Connor Hellebuyck is dialed in with a .939 save percentage while allowing two goals or fewer in 14 of his past 15 games. The Jets are also disciplined with the sixth-fewest minor penalties at 5-on-5 and the seventh-lowest shorthanded ice time per game.

Additionally, I’m anticipating tough on-ice matchups for Hertl. These two teams just met on December 12, and the Czech center was caved in to the tune of a 39.3 Corsi For percentage at 5-on-5. He lined up opposite Winnipeg’s top three centers, and Mark Scheifele, Adam Lowry, and Vladislav Namestnikov all drive possession and have a positive goal share at 5-on-5. 

I value the Tomas Hertl odds because he’s only found the scoresheet in three of the past 10 games and sports a 45.2 CF% and 35.4 goals-for percentage for the year.

Tomas Hertl prop: Under 0.5 points (+110 at Bet99)

Prop bet #3: Isles in sneaky shots spot

The New York Islanders head to Mullett Arena following consecutive road losses, including registering just 22 shots and 44 attempts while blowing multiple leads during a 5-4 overtime loss to the Colorado Avalanche on Tuesday. 

New York has topped 30 shots on net in nine of its past 14 games, and three of those five games that they failed to reach the benchmark were against teams ranking top five in shots-against per game. Put differently, when facing an opponent that doesn’t suppress shots among the league’s best, the Isles are putting pucks on net.

The Arizona Coyotes have surrendered the 11th most shots (31.2) per game, and the Islanders have climbed from 29.2 shots per to 31.0 during the noted 14-game stretch.

So, while ‘Yotes goalie Connor Ingram has lacked game-to-game consistency, he does boast a .919 save percentage. Additionally, despite being opportunistic, the Islanders struggle to capitalize. New York ranks 24th in high-danger goals per 60 minutes and 22nd in team shooting percentage at five-on-five.

Finally, I’m not expecting special teams to have a major impact on this prop. The Islanders have drawn the sixth-fewest minor penalties at 5-on-5, and the Coyotes have taken the 14th fewest while averaging the 11th-lowest shorthanded ice time per game.

It all adds up to value on Connor Ingram's odds in this saves market.

Connor Ingram prop: Over 26.5 saves (-120 at Bet99)

Not intended for use in MA.
Affiliate Disclosure: Covers may receive advertising commissions for visits to a sportsbook or betting site
.

Tonight’s NHL games

Google News
Stay updated with the latest picks, odds, and news! Tap the star to add us to your favorites on Google News to never miss a story.

Pages related to this topic

Betting Analyst

Neil Parker is, first and foremost, a sports fan. A huge supporter of the Cowboys, Cubs, and Maple Leafs, he has managed to parlay his passion into writing gigs with Sportsbook Review, USA TODAY, theScore, DraftKings Playbook, and RotoWire, among many others. He also co-hosted the Daily Fantasy Edge podcast and can now be seen offering expert golf and hockey advice on Covers’ Before you Bet broadcast.

Neil takes a numbers-based approach to his handicapping and complements his in-depth statistical analysis with a keen eye on the markets to provide the best available odds. He loves to lean on his rolodex of idioms to offset his inner nerd. When it comes to wagering, he throws down on anything that catches his eye at bet365, Betway and BetVictor. He also keeps a close eye on CoolBet because the polar bear brand often has outlier NHL and NFL moneyline prices.

Neil graduated with honors from St. Thomas University in 2007 before completing his BEd at Acadia University in 2010. After teaching a myriad of courses and subjects, he found a groove delivering fun lessons to exceptional learners in non-traditional classroom environments. If his decade-plus teaching run taught him anything about sports betting, it’s to stay the course and use the summer – or offseason – to refresh and prepare to be better in the year to come.

Neil’s top pieces of advice for recreational bettors are to stay within your means and to remember sportsbooks aren’t bank accounts. Don’t be afraid to pull those winnings and treat yourself to a lifetime experience courtesy of a big win.

Popular Content

Legal Canadian sports betting

Best Canadian betting sites Ontario sports betting
Covers 25 Years Logo Established in 1995,
Covers is the world
leader in sports
betting information.
Covers is verified safe by: Evalon Logo GPWA Logo GDPR Logo GeoTrust Logo Evalon Logo