need help on who to keep

Question

Can keep 2 of 3 between A. Foster, Vick, and C. Johnson.  12 team PPR league.  Leaning Foster and Vick right now.

xerri · Answer

Can keep 2 of 3 between A. Foster, Vick, and C. Johnson.  12 team PPR league.  Leaning Foster and Vick right now.

ragingstorm · Answer

Fuck that. Vick comes a dime a dozen. Without a doubt. Go for Fostor and Johnson. I won three straight years. I know my shit. A qb like Vick is easy to come by and quite frankly I think he is OVER RATED. Foster may be as good as last year but he and Johnson are the ones to keep without a doubt.

FrozenTundra · Answer

I agree. Think about replacement opps. QB depth this year is deep, RB depth is not. You can probably pick up Romo or Big Ben in 5-6th round who will probably avg 5-6pt below Vick week in week out worst case.

You can then go after 3 PPR studs in WR/TE

thisguyiswise · Answer

johnson and foster, qbs much much deeper

w8rh3wk5 · Answer

U need to get a feeler from the other teams who they r keeping. Vick is still a top 8 QB. And there is a major dropoff after that. If there r still top 8 qbs available in the third and fourth rounds than let Vick go, but if everyone is keeping their qbs, then u have to keep vick

Mr_Knuckles · Answer

ragingstorm.....I am in a 12 team, 1 player keeper league...standard scoring (except ALL TDs are 6 pts)Keep Vick or McFadden?Several teams are keeping QBs....P Manning, Big Ben, Rivers.....I like Vick because he is a duel threat, but I usually have issues with keeping a QB.Thoughts would be appreciated.xerri....I would go for Foster and Johnson in your position.  Tier 1 RB and WR.....What spot do you draft in ?

xerri · Answer

Problem with McFadden and Vick is they both have injury risk and can&#x27;t predict who will stay healthy.  Both are capable of huge numbers if they can play majority of the season.  Would probably take McFadden if PPR otherwise might be better off taking Vick as you may even be able to trade him for a top RB.Thanks for the input everyone.  I draft 8 but it looks like Rivers, Big Ben, Romo, and probably even Brady will be available as probably only Brees, Manning, and Rodgers will be kept so will keep Foster and Johnson and probably hope to get a QB in round 4 or 5.  Love Vick&#x27;s potential for high scoring games but I don&#x27;t think Vick will put up the same type of numbers and the injury risk is high.

need help on who to keep

Hot Forum Topics