Quote Originally Posted by melossinglet:
dude,this didnt even start out as a debate over philosophy or perceptions so stop trying to sound superior,like youre the smartest guy in the room or longing to live out your "good will hunting" fantasy...save all that bullshiit for another day and another thread.
cos all youre doing is trying to turn it into sumthing that has parameters whereby you can argue round and round in circles and make it into sum "chicken or egg" debate....so,youre the same as rostos cos clearly thats his favourite thing to do in the whole,wide world.
all we were asking of the guy,and any person of faith for that matter(and thats the key really cos in the end all they have is faith,not one iota of tangible evidence watsoever),is wat brought him to believe in the existence of a creator in terms of sum sort of verifiable,hard evidence..even if it is sumwat subjective....and so far surprise surprise surprise!!! hes offered absolutely nothing nada zero zip.(oh except for a whole bunch of sidetracking,deflecting and classical circular arguments of course)...just like every other damn religious person ive ever come across in my lifetime.
for sumthing as totally and utterly absurd and ridiculous as the existence of an all-knowing,all seeing,omni-present,eternal creator all the likes of myself,system and others are asking is just a skerrick of sumthing to support such lunacy.....like seriously,how the fu.kkkk can there be NOTHING over a period of thousands of years??...this god character never shows his face,says a thing,leaves a trail of bread-crumbs??....nothing???
and please dont feed me no horse-shiit about speaking to people in dreams or wat-not..theres all kinds of crazy folk that have all kinds of dreams about all kinds of stuff...catch sumthing on film at least,shiit theres more evidence of frickin big-foot than there is of a god
.
as for the ridiculous line of questioning about the origins of time,the universe and everything in it....well WE DONT KNOW.thats why we cant answer,but we dont just go and make a whole pile of fairytales and shiit up to try and explain it away to make ourselves feel better and more secure about our place on the earth.
and on the balance of probability and beyond all reasonable doubt we accept that other minds exist,anyone who suggests otherwise is being a semantic,petty,argumentative p.rick....as system clearly explained there is ample evidence all around every day that wat we classify as a thinking,feeling mind exists inside the skull of most...(i said most,rostos,most!!..not ALL)
so anyhow if you are a religious person,raiders 22,which is highly likely judging by the circuitous way you have gone about opposing the viewpoint offered here and the fact that you mite be the only person on the planet to identify with rostos in any way,shape or form........then wat leads you to believe in the existence of a god???
i dont wanna hear about how you look at the world,your perceptions or philosophies or any other garbage.....just wat convinces you one way or another
Rostos is the one who made the claims, he is the one that needs to back it up...instead he wants to side step and deflect
His quote "God is timeless, if he is timeless, he is eternal in the past, if he is eternal in the past, then he has no cause, if he has no cause the he has no beginning therefore and therefore he exists necessarily"
this is "true" because it is an attribute of classical theism
The problem with rostos is that he claims to know, where I can say I don't know and am ok with that.