AFL Round 5 - Discussion
Melbourne/Carlton
There's a couple of reasons why this is probably a pick for me but the main reason...
Carlton's biggest problem has been their defence, all other positions are up to par. The Dees on the other hand, IMO have a very poor forward line and can't be considered a threat in any game while its like it is. Their 2 main forwards neitz and Robbo were both match winners in their prime. They can still be a help to melbourne but they should really be second-stringers to another forward (that they don't have). Robbo squeaked out 3 goals last week but it was in the last 15mins when the game was lost and the pressure was off. Carlton's backs should have no problem nulifying these two whilst their onballers and forwards can be outstanding and should be against the Dees.
Melbourne/Carlton
There's a couple of reasons why this is probably a pick for me but the main reason...
Carlton's biggest problem has been their defence, all other positions are up to par. The Dees on the other hand, IMO have a very poor forward line and can't be considered a threat in any game while its like it is. Their 2 main forwards neitz and Robbo were both match winners in their prime. They can still be a help to melbourne but they should really be second-stringers to another forward (that they don't have). Robbo squeaked out 3 goals last week but it was in the last 15mins when the game was lost and the pressure was off. Carlton's backs should have no problem nulifying these two whilst their onballers and forwards can be outstanding and should be against the Dees.
Barry Hall. 6 weeks out imo. Bring back Nick Davis. No tantrums, longer kick, more accurate kick, greater speed, greater stamina, smarter player and half the price ![]()
If Hall is meant to be in the Senior leadership group goes out and does something stupid and lets the team down by being suspended 7 games or whatever it will be why isn't he dealt with like Davis was and still is. ![]()
AFL Death match: Cam Mooney vs Bazza Hall ![]()
Barry Hall. 6 weeks out imo. Bring back Nick Davis. No tantrums, longer kick, more accurate kick, greater speed, greater stamina, smarter player and half the price ![]()
If Hall is meant to be in the Senior leadership group goes out and does something stupid and lets the team down by being suspended 7 games or whatever it will be why isn't he dealt with like Davis was and still is. ![]()
AFL Death match: Cam Mooney vs Bazza Hall ![]()
- the dogs killed the saints
- if Hille didn't injure his shoulder the dons/dogs match would have been a hell of a lot closer, as he was dominating up to that point.
- the dogs killed the saints
- if Hille didn't injure his shoulder the dons/dogs match would have been a hell of a lot closer, as he was dominating up to that point.
Oh hell..................
Coming back into this forum is like a warm blanket on a cold, winter night.
I think I'll be staying in from now on, thank you.
Oh hell..................
Coming back into this forum is like a warm blanket on a cold, winter night.
I think I'll be staying in from now on, thank you.
*Bombers look the big value.
*Look at that price on Sydney!
*Hawthorn look value.
*Roos look value.
*Port look value as well, perhaps.
And it isn't that Collingwood is that bad....just Richmond is better. They played a very nice tactical game that suited their strengths and hit out at the Pies' weaknesses. I laid those out in an earlier thread for Round Four. Luckily, the paper stats came true on the pitch....as you know, that is not always the case. (Chelsea you bastards!
*Bombers look the big value.
*Look at that price on Sydney!
*Hawthorn look value.
*Roos look value.
*Port look value as well, perhaps.
And it isn't that Collingwood is that bad....just Richmond is better. They played a very nice tactical game that suited their strengths and hit out at the Pies' weaknesses. I laid those out in an earlier thread for Round Four. Luckily, the paper stats came true on the pitch....as you know, that is not always the case. (Chelsea you bastards!
(the one about Chelsea still stands though!
(the one about Chelsea still stands though!
hahaha I did that myself last week. I meant to play Germano but picked Sanchez in the SD v SF game.
hahaha I did that myself last week. I meant to play Germano but picked Sanchez in the SD v SF game.
https://www.eaglesflyinghigh.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=11944&st=0&sk=t&sd=a&sid=373c21960e4311edaa6e4860184d6556
https://www.eaglesflyinghigh.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=11944&st=0&sk=t&sd=a&sid=373c21960e4311edaa6e4860184d6556
Hot Forum Topics
- 🤢🥴💩_ Fubah's risky baseball bets _🥶😲🥵 457,411
- Sunday 10/04/2026 688
- NFL LOCKED IN! 104,347
- ***Macwesties * Sun. Oct. 04, 2026 * Week #4 * NFL Football Plays*** 8,616
- This Seattle Line Is Begging for a Discussion 2,823
- NCAA FOOTBALL. 151 33,499
- __________ 📌 🏈 ?? Fubah's NFL 2026: Week 04 🚩🚩🚩🚩 13,268
- Lions vs Panthers in game live SNF 1,878
- NFL THREAD * 151 * 16,849
- Los Angeles Rams @ Philadelphia Eagles 5,884
Warning - External Link
Report User
This post is spam
Delete Post
Remove Thread
Scan Results
Login/Register
Accounts are free and easy to create.
Search
