Kentucky Derby Picks: Best Trifecta, Superfecta, and Exacta Best Bets

Don't limit yourself to win, place, and show betting when you can make hundreds or even thousands going after the Kentucky Derby exacta, trifecta, or superfecta. Our horse racing betting picks see Honor Marie shaking things up in the exotics.

Robert Criscola - Contributor at Covers.com
Robert Criscola • Publishing Editor
May 4, 2024 • 14:58 ET • 4 min read
Honor Marie horse racing Kentucky Derby
Photo By - USA TODAY Sports

The 150th edition of the Kentucky Derby has arrived, and the first leg of the Triple Crown once again offers horse racing bettors an incredible wagering opportunity.

You could play it safe and simply make Kentucky Derby Win, Place and Show picks, but there are plenty of other wagers that could yield a much bigger payday.

I've evaluated the Kentucky Derby odds and am ready to make my best 2024 Kentucky Derby trifecta, superfecta, and exacta picks.

Kentucky Derby trifecta, superfecta, and exacta picks

Exacta pick

In order to hit the exacta, the bettor must select the Top 2 finishers of a race in order. The minimum wager is usually $1, but at Churchill Downs, the $1 straight exacta is not allowed. Only $1 part-wheels (e.g. 1/2,3) or boxes (where the bettor’s Kentucky Derby horses can finish first and second in any order, albeit at an increased cost) are permitted.

No. 17 Fierceness (5-2) is the most likely winner of the 2024 Kentucky Derby despite drawing wide in the Kentucky Derby post positions. His win in the 2023 Breeders' Cup Juvenile was impressive, but he outdid himself by romping in the Florida Derby to punch his ticket to the first Saturday in May.

I'm willing to forgive Fierceness' effort in the Holy Bull Stakes, as it came off a layoff and he suffered a very poor start.

No. 2 Sierra Leone (3-1) might just be good enough to run the top pick down late — it could just be a matter of pace. The son of Gun Runner has lost only once in four starts, and it came in the Remsen Stakes at age two when he spotted many lengths as well as a gold rail to Dornoch, who wired the field.

Sierra Leone closed from well back yet won by open lengths in both the Risen Star Stakes and the Blue Grass Stakes to prep for the Kentucky Derby.

Pari-mutually speaking, I'm throwing No. 4 Catching Freedom (8-1), No. 7 Honor Marie (20-1), and No. 8 Just a Touch (10-1) under a blanket in my principal exacta play, as I think any of those runners can land second if they fire their best shots. 

Catching Freedom won the 1 3/16th-mile Louisiana Derby to prep for this, and he has arguably the best jockey in the country aboard in Flavien Prat. I like him just a bit more than the other two and will have some saver exactas with him on top.

Honor Marie was second to Catching Freedom in the Louisiana Derby but owns a key Kentucky Jockey Club Stakes score over Churchill Downs. Just a Touch has just one win to date but earned solid speed figures in both the Gotham Stakes and the Blue Grass Stakes, placing second each time, to earn his way into the "Run for the Roses."

$4 exacta pick:

  • To win: No. 17 Fierceness
  • Second place: No. 2 Sierra Leone, No. 4 Catching Freedom, No. 7 Honor Marie, No. 8 Just a Touch 

$2 exacta pick:

  • To win: No. 2 Sierra Leone, No. 4 Catching Freedom
  • Second place: No. 7 Honor Marie, No. 8 Just a Touch, No. 17 Fierceness

$1 exacta pick:

  • To win: No. 2 Sierra Leone, No. 17 Fierceness
  • Second place: No. 2 Sierra Leone, No. 17 Fierceness

Total = $30

Kentucky Derby picks and predictions

Our experts are making Kentucky Derby picks and building bets all week.

Trifecta pick

The trifecta tasks the bettor with picking the first three finishers of a race in exact order. The payoff can be substantially higher than the exacta, but so too are the potential ticket costs and risk factors.

One benefit horseplayers have when it comes to the trifecta compared to the exacta or superfecta for the Kentucky Derby is the minimum wager amount, which in this case is 50 cents. That enables the bettor to include more combinations while keeping costs at a reasonable level.

I'll keep my trifecta costs under control by leaning more heavily on Fierceness to finish first. I'll do a saver play involving Sierra Leone finishing first and Fierceness second with no other horses in the Top 2 rungs.

$2 trifecta pick:

  • To win: No. 17 Fierceness
  • Second place: No. 2 Sierra Leone, No. 4 Catching Freedom, No. 7 Honor Marie, No. 8 Just a Touch 
  • Third place: No. 2 Sierra Leone, No. 4 Catching Freedom, No. 7 Honor Marie, No. 8 Just a Touch 

$1 trifecta pick:

  • To win: No. 2 Sierra Leone, No. 17 Fierceness
  • Second place: No. 2 Sierra Leone, No. 17 Fierceness
  • Third place: No. 4 Catching Freedom, No. 7 Honor Marie, No. 8 Just a Touch 

Total = $30

Best horse racing bonuses

FanDuel New Users
$500 No Sweat First Bet! Claim Now

bet365 New Users
Bet $5, get $150 in bonus bets! Claim Now

Eligible USA locations only. Also, see our full list of best sportsbook promotions for 2024.
21+. Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER

Superfecta pick

The superfecta is often one of the best-paying wagers at the track, but it's also among the trickiest to hit as the bettor must select the Top 4 finishers of a race in exact order. The superfecta minimum for the Derby is $1, and that makes constructing an affordable ticket that much more difficult, but it also increases the chances for a huge mutuel.

A five-horse superfecta box at the $1 minimum costs a prohibitive $120, so I'm looking to keep things simple in this pool and trying to maximize the payout in the event Fierceness does come through for trainer Todd Pletcher's third career Derby score.

$1 Superfecta pick:

  • To win: No. 17 Fierceness
  • Second place: No. 2 Sierra Leone, No. 4 Catching Freedom, No. 7 Honor Marie, No. 8 Just a Touch
  • Third place: No. 2 Sierra Leone, No. 4 Catching Freedom, No. 7 Honor Marie, No. 8 Just a Touch
  • Fourth place: No. 2 Sierra Leone, No. 4 Catching Freedom, No. 7 Honor Marie, No. 8 Just a Touch

Total = $24

Where can I bet on the Kentucky Derby?

Several legal horse racing betting sites allow you to wager on the Kentucky Derby, but not every sportsbook is allowed to offer odds on the Derby. Our guide outlines the best Kentucky Derby betting sites available in your area.

Which states have legal betting on the Kentucky Derby?

While sports bettors can enjoy some form of online or retail wagering in 34 states (+ DC), horse racing enthusiasts have even more legal options. Refer to our list of legal states for betting on horse racing to see if horse race betting is legal in your state via the FanDuel Racing app.

Canada (excluding Ontario)

Almost all sports betting sites offer fixed-odds betting on horse racing. Check out the best sports betting sites in Canada or sign up now with one of our top partners, bet365, and earn up to $200 in bet credits!

Ontario

Following the changes to the iGaming regulations on April 4, 2022, horse racing betting is no longer available at sportsbooks. Those in Ontario who are looking to bet on the Kentucky Derby will need to sign up at one of Woodbine's two online offerings, HPIbet and Dark Horse Bets.

Kentucky Derby betting FAQs

Pages related to this topic

Robert Criscola - Covers.com
Publishing Editor

Robert M. Criscola’s road to becoming a Covers publishing editor began with an internship at Metro New York, which eventually turned into a freelance job at MetroBet covering many sports from a wagering angle, including horse racing. He continued to focus on “The Sport of Kings” by writing for shapperdacapper.com, danonymousracing.com, and informer.fanxt.com before joining the team at the TwinSpires Edge in 2019 as a regular contributor and weekend editor. “Crisco” began writing game previews for Covers in 2022 and joined the editing team in 2023.

His best advice for sports bettors? Bet with your head, not over it.

Popular Content

Legal Canadian sports betting

Best Canadian betting sites Ontario sports betting
Covers is verified safe by: Evalon Logo GPWA Logo GDPR Logo GeoTrust Logo Evalon Logo