The blame for not "opening up the playbook" shouldnt be placed on the shoulders of McElwain. It's Saban. Playing conservative, not putting his QB in a position to make the big mistake, etc Thats his style. Control the clock, establish the run and let his defense win/loss the games. For example, look at his LSU teams vs the Florida State teams of the last 2 years. Jimbo will open it up and loves to do so. Saban handcuffs his coordinators and micromanages the game. But its tough to complain or moan about it becaause it works.