This committe is completely lost

Quote Originally Posted by naesiy:

Nothing against you bro, so don't take this the wrong way...but do you have any reading comprehension?  Let me break it down for you...

Boom used a double standard to strengthen his argument both ways...on one hand, he tried to pump up FSU's SOS resume by noting only "current" top 25 teams in comparison to TCU's wins.

Then, when trying to discount Oregon's SOS, he disregards that Arizona is CURRENTLY in the top 25 and instead notes that when Oregon lost to AZ, AZ was UNRANKED and a 24 point dog. 

I asked Boom to clarify which is it, current rankings or is it gametime rankings that should matter as obviously, AZ shouldn't have been a 24 point dog to the ducks.  He responded by defining the meaning of current, which was not the question.

Therefore, it's obvious that his reading comprehension, along with yours it seems, inabsence of a better word, is lacking...hence, my LAST response that will be directed towards him.  I now understand where he is "at" and feel no further need to discuss any topic with him.  I fully understand why he posts the things he posts.    I'll no longer clutter the circle jerk that is boom's threads. 

Quote Originally Posted by naesiy:

 

So that 3 point win by Baylor occuring IN WACO means nothing correct?  I can't remember who it was but there's a dude on here that's always harping on how "WHERE" a game is played is arguably the biggest and most important factor in college football....

except when it's detrimental to the argument you are trying to make, obviously....

Quote Originally Posted by Shark_Attack:

Quote Originally Posted by Boom_Boom:



But the trump card is BAYLOR BEAT TCU


That's all that should matter

Quote Originally Posted by Boom_Boom:



I dont know about that....at all


So what are you saying... there needs to be built in excuses?


Let's say Watson starts at QB for Clemson from day .....should that be accounted for? IMO, NO..... because the game was played and coaching decisions were made.

  

Quote Originally Posted by toddo1:

 

Quote Originally Posted by warcameagle56:

U are one of the few that thinks the committee got it wrong.Actually,it looks about perfect to me.Folks are gonna get real mad if Auburn beats Georgia & Bama then moves up and just steals that #4 spot.Boom, people as they should don't care about the 2013 FSU team.They also don't care about point spreads.They watch the film and they see an average FSU team.Don't u think there is a reason Vegas has FSU a 2pt.favorite @Miami.My guess is they see that the Cane Frosh Qb is fitting in and putting up good numbers that will challenge FSU's 1/trick pony Winston to Green.There is a reason why Auburn is the highest ranked 2 loss team & was the highest 1loss team when they had 1 loss.Its called R E S P E C T.They saw the flukey blocked fg for a TD and 2/fumbles Auburn had and their offense scoring at will producing 350 yards rushing.I can't see one thing I would argue.I actually do think your Tigers should be ahead of Arizona...As devastating as the A&M loss was at the time maybe all it did was piss Auburn it off so they could take it out on Georgia.We strongly disagree on Ole Miss.Darn good football team and according to Vegas( who I think is wrong)they beat the best team in CFB in Bama.I have no idea why Bama is a 8.5 point fav against MissSt...Robinson of MissSt is a great Rb and will need 100/yarss I think to win.I like Minnesota to beat Ohio St Sat morn.I was joking about that Buckeye post then Your boy Snyder needs to pull the upset at Baylor or Charlie Strong needs to get his first signature win beating TCU in Austin and some can stick that GOLDEN Horshoe where the sun don't shine...Hey Packers,Auburn is BACK!...Me and Kevin Scarbinsky talked for about 15min today about it and he absolutely believes it.The committee doesn't like FSU because they think Jimbo is making a mockery...Just is funny to me Boom how u don't want to give a team credit that WON at #10 then lost at home to #24 on a ToTAL FLUKE...Nobody can stop that offense of Auburn.CAP is out performing Tre Mason...The Defense needs lots of tweeking...Whether u like it or not AUBURN  IS ABSOLUTELY KNOCKING ON DOOR and ARE IN IF THEY WIN.They will get the help.If they don't there is always Cotton Bowl right?

Quote Originally Posted by mattbrot:

But for the record the fact that FSU has not lost since 2012 should have 0 influence on this season. It means nothing and is a very annoying argument.

Quote Originally Posted by Sabanade:

Yep, and in 2014..... Oregon lost AT HOME to an UNRANKED Arizona team.

Quote Originally Posted by holtnt:

Boom,

 

I am with you there...  TCU had Baylor dead to rights in Waco (which is a tough place to play I might add), but they lose none the less; however, TCU went into Morgantown, WV and won which Baylor was unable to do so… 

Quote Originally Posted by Wutangodb:

I respect your opinion boom, and you have a point that the champs are still unbeaten, and the committee is still in it's infancy and had a lot of stuff to bring into play, and quality of wins is a big part in the decision making

I think it's hard to say that FSU would be unbeaten if they played the same schedule as TCU, or Miss St, or Ole miss, or ANY SEC team. They are unbeaten, which is why they're still in the top 4, but they've not been impressive in a lot of their wins. Their defense is atrocious. If they played in the SEC I think they'd have an absolute minimum of 2 losses.

I see where you're coming from but personally I think I could name 10 teams off the top of my head that are better then Florida state, and if they make it to the playoff, I think they're going to get demolished.

Quote Originally Posted by Sabanade:

Maybe we will get the SEC Champ #1 and FSU #4 and they meet up in New Orleans to find out. I would love to see it.