Quote Originally Posted by TheBuddah:
Kc is better in sagarin rank 3 vs 10 and schedule strength at 16 vs 25.
Like your analysis overall, but this is definitely where you went off the rails. Sagarin is lazy, washed up, and his power rankings and SOS rankings should be ignored by EVERYBODY who is trying to handicap sports. I've looked deeply into his numbers, and they are NOT CLOSE!
The specific problem with his SOS rankings is that one of his primary factors in determining those ranks is based on something that has ZERO relevance to this season: for some absolutely inexplicable reason (I assume it is pure laziness)... he factors in each teams ranking in their division from the previous year.
Let me explain this... the Chiefs finished first in their division last year, so they get what the NFL deems a "First place schedule." This means they play against all teams that were also first place in their own conference, as well as 2 of the first place teams from the opposing conference. So at the start of the season, Sagarin has this already factored into their SOS, because it allows him to add data early on, where very little data is otherwise available.
Here's the problem: the teams that finished in 1st place last year in their divisions include the Rams, the Packers, the Buccs, and the Titans... 3 teams that rate somewhere between below average and absolutely terrible. Meanwhile, some of the 3rd and 4th place teams made a huge leap this year. Teams with 3rd place schedules had to play against teams like the 49ers, Dolphins, Chargers and Redskins, while teams with 4th place schedules had to play against teams like the Ravens, Jags, Lions, Giants and Seahawks.
To put it simply... teams that had a 3rd or 4th place schedule this year, in most cases, had a MUCH more brutal schedule than the first place teams. Miami had a 3rd place schedule, but had easily the most difficult schedule this season, IF it is NOT based on what happened LAST YEAR! Since SOS is a major factor in his power rankings, that means both the SOS and PR are WORTHLESS!
Sagarin's ratings are absolute TRASH! Do not ever use them... and I say this as someone who used to respect what he does. You want SOS rankings... come to me!