Also... I know I'm a homer, but I'd put Mike Wallace on that list before Vincent Jackson. No way is Jackson even close to top 10. Also, I'd have to put Welker in there at the 3 or 4 spot. Dwayne Bowe and Wallace may be top 10 next year.
Good list browndog.
HERE YA GO...improved
1. a.johnson
2. l.fitzgerald
3.calvin.johnson
4. d.jackson
5. b.marshall
6. a. boldin
7. v.jackson
8. dwayne bowe
9. g.jennings
10. r. moss
Randy Moss? Really?
Just another example of why Covers should drug test each poster before giving them posting privileges.
thanks for the info
My list:-
1. A Johnson (No arguments there)
2. L.Fitzgerald (Could compete with No.1 if he had a QB - remember Warner).
3. Calvin Johnson - Seriously, if only he had a QB, you'd logically think he could compete for No.1.
4. R. White - Don't think you could argue against him not being in the top 5 based on consistency and reliability.
5. B.Marshall - Big, strong, young, QBs could pass to him with confidence. Would be a lot higher if he had opportunities to collect TDs.
6. R.Moss - hates gonna hate but ask yourself this. Come week 1 if Brady was passing to him, what are your expectations? Old legs, lacks motivation and can be lazy (not to mention he had a bad season) puts him down here, but until he shows me one more bad season, he can't go lower than the WRs below this.
7. Reggie Wayne - Argh, should he be this low? Makes me wonder why I rated R.White 4 over this guy. Because he has Manning, production will always be there but only time will tell if he'll gradually fade out.
8, 9, 10 in no particular order D.Jackson, A. Boldin, G.Jennings (throw in M.Colston too for consideration)
My list:-
1. A Johnson (No arguments there)
2. L.Fitzgerald (Could compete with No.1 if he had a QB - remember Warner).
3. Calvin Johnson - Seriously, if only he had a QB, you'd logically think he could compete for No.1.
4. R. White - Don't think you could argue against him not being in the top 5 based on consistency and reliability.
5. B.Marshall - Big, strong, young, QBs could pass to him with confidence. Would be a lot higher if he had opportunities to collect TDs.
6. R.Moss - hates gonna hate but ask yourself this. Come week 1 if Brady was passing to him, what are your expectations? Old legs, lacks motivation and can be lazy (not to mention he had a bad season) puts him down here, but until he shows me one more bad season, he can't go lower than the WRs below this.
7. Reggie Wayne - Argh, should he be this low? Makes me wonder why I rated R.White 4 over this guy. Because he has Manning, production will always be there but only time will tell if he'll gradually fade out.
8, 9, 10 in no particular order D.Jackson, A. Boldin, G.Jennings (throw in M.Colston too for consideration)
NewDarkDay, whilst I respect your opinion in regards to Randy Moss, this thread asked for "Top 10 WRs" and "Top" could be defined as many things, whether you judge a WR by their consistency, performance, statistics etc...so many variables and factors.
However, all things being equal (like WRs having same talent core around them to ease double coverage or having the same talented QB), I rate L.Fitzgerald 2nd because I deemed him to be the 2nd best WR in the game today. Yes I agree he should be a bit lower because of the QB situation.
As for Randy Moss, I don't seeing him in the top 5 today. Last season was just tragic with so much drama, but it takes more than one season to write him off completely out of the top 5 because he's proven for 12 season he is one of the very best so you can't judge off one unmotivated season!
Established in 1995,
Hot Forum Topics
