who had the better career ? Eli or Rodgers or Peyton ?

who had the best career ?

Two teams two super bowls do the math.

@wewinandone

The guy who went out on top.

2 SB, 2 Teams.

Not even close.

Peyton is a GOAT

Probably Peyton, Eli and then Rodgers 

@JohnnyChalk

 truth

@Boa33

 with a barely over 500 playoff record ?

@THE_PRESIDENT 

took 7 years to get 1 another 9 years to get another which the defense won ,  2-2 50% superbowl record is that really the best ?

@skillahmang

 How ? 

@JohnnyChalk

 Ill go Eli , Peyton , Rodgers 

@Boa33

 what beating the goat of the era two times and be undefeated in Superbowls ? 

Peyton, Rodgers, Eli 

The Giants won due to the team and the defense not due to Eli IMO.

@wallstreetcappers

check the stats , Eli ad great passing yards and game control, you have to score to win games, all teams need a great defense to win games ask Brady and Peyton 

Is this even a question?

Eli was the best playoff QB Out of all of them. Peyton was the best overall.

Rodgers won 1 super bowl which is pretty sad considering all the numbers

and accolades he got.

@AJ86

 yup , as most casuals will say Peyton 

@wallstreetcappers

Eli made 2 game winning drives in Super Bowl to win , the defense didnt do that 

@Brooklyncapper

 nice take

@wallstreetcappers

Our defense was great in those 2 super bowl years but Eli was the

reason we won those super bowls. It was him that wiggled out

of a sack and made the throw of the super bowl to Tyree.

It was him who threw a rope to Manningham for his own 12 yard

line. It was him that hit the Hail mary against Rodgers packers

in gbay. It was him that stuck it out in -20 degrees and outdid

Favre in the frozen tundra. So many big plays by him in both

super bowl runs.

Peyton, Eli, Rodgers. 

@Brooklyncapper

 People forget how great Eli was during both of those playoff runs 

Easy…Peyton, Eli and Aaron. 

@Brooklyncapper

 Eli played well during the season , defense will always be key to a dominate season , remember who won the majority of the SBs for the Patriots 

@TSix

 explain why its ez