who had the better career ? Eli or Rodgers or Peyton ?

@AJ86

 bad teams , most of the team had gone by then

@AJ86

 a pro bowl ? hahaha 

tom bradys hero is peyton manning 

@skillahmang

 who said stats dont matter ? 

Petyon 251 ints / ei 244 

Peyton yard per catch 7.7/ Eli 6.7 

TD 346 Eli / Petyon 559 with 30 more game played , at the  same game mark , Peyton was 440 td 225 ints 

yards Eli 57,000/ Petyon 71,000 with 30 more game played , Peyton at the game mark of Eli Peyton was as  61,560 passing yards

if you can see by these stats there is not as big of a distance as you think it is. You a causal that watches ESPN for your determination. 

Eli not even close and so humble

Interestingly.......Manning had a career passer rating of 84.1 .....utterly mediocre....although he played on some mediocre teams for sure....but against the Patriots and their tough defense he had a rating of 96.2......so he stepped it up......he only had 3 touchdowns in the two games combined....but obviously had the huge moments and played solid football......that Giants defensive line should was as much an map as Eli.....but he came thru when it counted....those two runs.....no doubt about it......

@theMno he made peyton look good , if he didnt throw to him it was picked off 

@charliel

go stats for stats 

@vinnyherbert

 nice take 

@vinnyherbert

 also here is a list of 84 passer rating avg qb that we all admire 

Dan Marino 

Jim Kelly 

Brett favre Roger st

So because he was put in the Giants Ring of Honor and they retired his number that means something?

You are making this too easy.

So what you are saying is if we remove the 30 extra games, Peyton still had almost 100 more tds and 19 less ints.

Okay got it

@AJ86

 YUP how many players have their numbers retired and are in the team hall of honor ?

Ya and its not even close.

@AJ86

  Naw this notion that Peyton is extremely better has been debunked 251 interceptions wow 

Well Peyton is in 2 and Eli is in 1.

What do you want to compare next? How both of them did against Vanderbilt in their college years?

@AJ86

 what I'm saying is that he should not have that many Interceptions , to go along with 1 super bowl in your 12 and a TD / INt ratiso of 1/1 , but he didnt have more super bowls at that time now did he ?

@AJ86

 I showed how close they are , 

Phil Sims won a Superbowl MVP. I'm assuming he is as good as Rodgers since he only 1 as well.

Don't forget that Malcolm Smith won a Superbowl MVP with Seattle. He is clearly as good if not better than Ray Lewis.

Your argument is flawed all over the place. Eli caught lightening in a bottle twice in his career in January/February. Other than that he was mediocre in the league. Nothing special. Won a couple games he should have lost. Lost a couple games he should have won.

Definitely not Payton Manning as I can't stand that guy and his NFL parting gift the year of his retirement with a Superbowl ring against the best team in football the Carolina panthers with a 15-1 record and the best defense in football that year miraculously fumbles the football on the opening kickoff and the rest was history as Sheriff Manning gets to ride into the sunset with a gifted Superbowl retirement ring.....yeah okay!

@wewinandone

 So if your in a superbowl, who are you starting. Eli or Peyton? Simple question. 

@AJ86

 The backup!