Quote Originally Posted by sundance:
wall, .Random opinions follow. I want to see the smokestacks spewing clean smoke again. I want to see the coal miners in West Virginia mining coal. I am tired of being called a denier with the threat of jail if I don't believe in global warming. I want a shirt and a pair of pants made in America that are now made in Viet Nam. I want the US to be energy independent. Globalization needs to be confronted on all fronts as Trump/Pence did for Carrier. Final number regarding Carrier. 700k for 10 years. Very small number to keep American jobs in Indiana.
See the issue as you bring up and people fail to understand is if you want to keep jobs here and you want people to not live like those in Vietnam, China, India etc etc then we have to pay MORE for our goods to accomplish this.
A good example is housing...so everyone knows I live in the general PHX metro area and there are a large range of housing prices here like in many metro areas. I have many decisions I can make and depending on what variables I am interested in I can either spend 80k on a house or I can spend 300k. I say 80k to 300k because based on an average 1500 sf house I could buy one down here for between 80k and 300k. The 80k house puts me in an area of the city that is less desirable, has greater risks and lower standards and likely an older house while a 300k house probably puts me in one of the nicer parts of town, newer house, safer area and less risk.
I was shopping the other day and I saw that a store was selling a pair of Wrangler jeans for 15 bucks, I thought to myself first that I dont buy Wrangler but second that this cost is LOWER than when I was in high school...and I knew exactly why this was the case..aside from the likely lower quality of jeans (I am positive that corporations have cheapened the quality of raw inputs to save money) that the bulk of the "cost" in the savings comes from the manufacturing and labor...and to make jeans the cost of machinery probably isnt all that high so their savings comes from offshoring production to a lower labor pool...like as you mentioned Vietnam.
People are not willing to pay more for a product if it means that production is kept here and that some lower middle class jobs are available for people in Indiana. Residential and small businesses are not willing to pay more for a Carrier product because they keep some mid range labor jobs in Indiana...they will jump ship and go buy a Goodman made in Mexico because Goodman and others can offshore and are not penalized so they artificially are able to be more competitive than someone conducting all facets of their business here.
The reality is that government is being controlled by corporations in order for them to take advantage of a lower cost labor pool, lower cost input pool and sell products in competition with companies who do not offshore (yet). So while Trump claims to be something he ISNT regarding being a tough guy and this whole lame act of his, to "save" these jobs his VP is subsidizing Carrier, its the same as Carrier raising prices because the payment of this subsidy comes from taxation...and that always trickles down to the consumer and thus the consumer pays for Carrier's freebies.
The real answer is two-fold and obvious...first we have to rid our process of lobbying and dark money then politicians have a chance at leveling the playing field and penalizing offshoring and INCREASE taxation to those that do offshore, because taxing offshoring corps (as most countries do) relieves the burden on the smallest citizen. If I were able to do what I think I would INCREASE taxation of offshore funds and production...so if Apple wants to keep cash made from offshoring in some Swiss bank then they are not allowed to sell their products here until the balance of taxes are paid period. Playing soft with these corporations isnt working, it doesnt work.
Second is that as citizens we cannot expect things to change when we want our cheap goods and we also want our manufacturing jobs here...it doesnt work that way, if you want jobs here and you want people to have a reasonable standard of living then the costs of goods here has to go up..our CPI has been flat for well over a decade, how is that possible? We all benefit from offshoring, so as a country we have to either be willing to subsidize, penalize or be willing to pay more in order to make jobs available here and the products made able to be sold here.