SEC is SOOOOO overrated!

Bullshit i been reading these forums and its the 1st time i seen an Alabama fans point this out about Iowa State.

Fucking Alabama haters and haddicapper33 you have been hateing on Alabama all year, so anything coming from you Alabama fans already expect it.....

Another thing back during the 1st of college football season this year we had a discussion about you're outlook on home field advantage.

Just to point that out before you say i'm saying it now because Alabama lost at home in overtime okay!

People can go back and look at you're posts, you're biggest hangup all year not just the Alabama vs LSU game is homefield advantage...

Find some new things to post about because it's always the same shit.....

HAHA!!  Anyone notice the OP never mentions OSU and defense together? 

Say What??? Check your stats before you make a stupid comment like that....

Lets run through LSU's Schedule to see who they played each week and that teams rank for the week...

Week 1 Oregon (Ranked 3rd)

Week 3 Mississippi State (Ranked 25th)

Week 4 West Virginia (Ranked 16th)

Week 6 Florida (Ranked 17th)

Week 8 Auburn (Ranked 20th)

Week 10 Alabama (Ranked 2nd)

Week 13 Arkansas (Ranked 3rd)

Week 14 Georgia (Ranked 14th)

So LSU is 7-0 agaisnt teams in the top 25 this season.. Soon to be 8-0 after they beat Georgia on saturday.

no... DOUBLE-BULLSHIT!  in this thread alone i have seen that argument about 50 times... join us in reality, will you?

wow!  i don't even know why i looked back on this... thinking somebody would have SOMETHING!

i am going to regret even addressing this, but whatever!  LAWYER!

you just listed their rankings AT THE TIME THEY PLAYED... who gives a flying FUCK???  that is totally meaningless... are you kidding me!?  THIS is what you come up with to try to dispute my argument...

are you gonna sit there and try to tell me that Miss St is a top 25 team?  that Florida and Auburn are top 20 teams?

i am talking about END OF YEAR rankings... REAL SHIT!  real shit that actually fucking matters... see, that's what i do... i don't try to twist the shit into something it isn't, and bring up convoluted stats that cloud the debate... i show you the REAL SHIT!

give it a fucking try... beginning of year rankings are well-known to be one of the WORST things about CFB... end of year rankings are the only thing that matters... and besides, i was NOT using BCS rankings (i assume you are), specifically because this is a debate about whose PERFORMANCE is the best... and the BCS system uses HUMAN VOTERS...

basically, as best as possible, i took the human voters out of the equation, and gave you just the raw data... the same thing you will get from the computer rankings, which are just measuring performance, with as little bias as possible...

Hawk... why does it matter who they lost to, but it doesn't matter who they've beaten? It does. Bama had a tougher schedule

go back and read my post comparing this to the Boise debate from last year... then it was all about the fact they hadn't beaten anybody... now it's all about who you lost to... Can't. I can't bring up the last 5 years, you can't go back to Boise.....I mean, fair is fair

that's horseshit! you can't have it both ways... Sure you can. Try.


which is EXACTLY why i looked at the entire body of work... and THAT is how you really measure up two teams... Uh, no. That is how YOU measure two teams



in logic, you take your argument to the extreme, if you want to test it and find out whether or not it is valid...Since we're going to use logic, you'll note that there is more than one argument:the Bama side, and the Cowboy side

let's take your argument to the extreme... what if Alabama played Sun Belt teams the entire year, with a game against LSU sprinkled right in the middle... they would still only have 1 loss to LSU... would they still get to use your argument? And if Ok.St played a Sun Belt schedule and only lost to Iowa State?

so the question becomes, where is the line at which that argument completely falls apart? and the answer is... it falls apart as soon as you can take it to the extreme and see that it falls apart...If you only examine one side of equation, yes. But we're talking about TWO teams here, Sparky

you cannot kill the OSU argument in the same manner... as long as we have a situation with two 1-loss teams... my argument remains valid at both ends of the spectrum, but yours does not! Your argument is not valid. You are not looking at both ends of the spectrum, only at the Bama side.

The facts are: the SEC is not overrated. You may think so, but that does not make it so. The polls, the computer, the tv ratings, even the posters on this board, are the majority. Keep fighting, though. I'll look forward to what you'll have to say when Ok.St becomes a 2-loss team......

You're right!!  defense is a totally meaningless issue in the big 12.  i wouldnt mention it either if i was a fan of those teams. 

New ID??  LMAO!!!  I have a job sir.  Ever hear of one??  I dont sit here and stare at my computer waiting to make one dumbass comment after another......unlike other people......

You can say that, but shit happens throughout the season and people get hurt, suspended, etc... then the teams start falling down... also after losing they drop in ranking... Of all the teams that played OSU, how many played LSU or Alabama? if they had, they wouldnt be ranked that high right now because they would have lost.

but IF you look at it that way then....

Week 1  Oregon (Ranked 9th)

Week 4 West Virginia (Ranked 23rd)

Week 10 Alabama (Ranked 2nd)

Week 13 Arkansas (Ranked 8th)

Week 14 Georgia (Ranked 14th)

That means LSU has won 4 games against teams in the top 23 and will have won 5 games after saturday.

Now that I think about it even more.... The only way to compare it is to compare week to week.... to compare it to the end of the season seems like you are twisting the facts.... that is not how they were ranked when they played eachother... the only fair way in my opinion is to look at it the way I did. The reason Oregon dropped from number 3 to number 13 after week 1 is because they lost to LSU... if they hadnt played LSU this year, they might be in the top 4.. Same for Arkansas, had they not played LSU last week, they would be ranked higher.

So to compare the caliber of teams played at the end of the season rankings looking back on games played throughout the season is stupid in my opinion.

Honestly Tappy... I am an LSU fan... and I bet the ML that LSU would win against Bama... I won.... but I was on the edge of my seat the whole game... And in all honesty, LSU shouldnt have won that game.. Bama played better, they just need to recruit a better FG kicker.... That being said, LSU was playing at Bama.. The BCS Championship is at the superdome this year and that is as good as a home field advantage. LSU has won the NC the last two times it was played in NOLA... My guess is a threepeat.

I would love to see a rematch against those two teams because if LSU faces anyone else, it wont be a good game.

Human error still there. Case in point, the programmers left out two teams from the "algorithms" in the first few weeks.

Therefore by definition--skewed results and error.

Isn't your argument that the BCS is flawed? If you don't have a cotentious point to make, you're bored. You and most others in this thread are windbags w/way too much time on your hands. Write less.

QUOTE Originally Posted by Lucan:

Bullshit i been reading these forums and its the 1st time i seen an Alabama fans point this out about Iowa State.

Good golly Mrs Gully please, in this thread alone . I was not going to say nothing to you but since you brought my name up to come to US REALITY why don't you count all of US on your one hand and i'll count All of us on two hands that think you're full of shit.

If you're not full of shit....

You have a chance right now to prove it....

If you don't prove it everybody that reads this knows you're full of shit....

You're play:

Put the poat number # ------ of every Alabama fan in this thread that :

Where they bought up Iowa State before i made the post #151.

What you said 50 times in this thread okay give everybody the #No------ of each post all 50 too!

1. -----------2.------------3.-----------4.-----------5.-----------6.----------7.---------

8.-----------9.----------10.----------11.-----------12.----------13.--------14.-------

15.--------16.---------17.---------18.---------19.---------20.---------21.---------

22.---------23.--------24.---------25.---------26.---------27.---------28.---------

29.--------30.---------31.---------32.---------33.---------34.-------35.---------

36.--------37.--------38.---------39.--------40.---------41.---------42.--------

43.--------44.--------45.--------46.---------47.-------48.-------49-------50.------

Everybody  <

If this can't be done we all know he talks SHIT...

totally agree. they would kill them.  bama would beat them 38-13

they would be way to phyiscal for the box cowboys.  bama is going to beat LSU which makes  this person thread started by ice4blood a joke.