So lets say JJ McCarthy goes down and out for the season against Iowa. Are they left out the playoffs too?

@DeezyAZ81

 Blown out by Alabama? If that’s the case and. Couple that with the diatribe you’re spewing about FSU deserving to be in ……then I can assume you believe FSU would also blow out Michigan had they been th 4th spot?

look forward to your response

FSU isn’t top 4 or even top 10 without their qb….

The committee decided. Not me. When FSU gets boat raced by UGA it will make sense. 

Why is #6 -13.5 over #5 who you think should be in the top 4?

thankful to see another SANE human in here. Welcome!

Geo not consider the 4 best team ? 
bama got their ass wipe by texas too and still get in

geo perfect all season n lose the last game and they from 1 down to 6 is ridiculous as well 

BAMA beat the #1 ranked, defending National CHAMP!   They won THE SEC, which has won how many out of the last 20 titles?  

Fk Ohio St would beat the sheit out of FSU if not Oregon who only lost to the #2 ranked team twice. 

I struggle to understand.  Do the FSU backers seriously want to see them get ‘rewarded’ with a thirty-five point drubbing in the playoffs??  If the God-knows-how-many guys on Georgia that are NFL bound choose to actually play in the Orange Bowl they’ll get a good dose of reality.

But yet they've remained a top 4 team voted by the same committee.  Not only that, FSU we're ranked 5 prior to last week and then moved up back #4.  While I'll agree they have not looked like a top 4 team for weeks, my only question to you is why were they?

Exactly. I think Michigan is highly overrated in a bad conference.No clue how they are in or the #1 seed for that matter. Bama or FSU would beat them handily as Michigan will not and would not score on either. 

Means nothing but bias.. Will be a tight game. Remember Oregon was supposed to blow out Washington as -10.5 favorites on Friday and we see how that turned out. 

Vandy, South Carolina, and Miss State. Juggernauts. 

@DeezyAZ81

  2 week ago..an average/bad SEC Kentucky team went on the road an beat a 10-1 Ville team that played in the ACC ship game. FSU struggled mightily vs Ville....Maybe Ville should have beaten a bad Kentucky team that both Georgia and Bama destroyed and then FSU beats an even higher ranked top 7-10 Ville team and maybe just maybe FSU would have gotten in...

@benhogan76

 Ask Louisville. They suck till you play a Kentucky, auburn or even a lsu with zero defense. 

We don’t have to like it. We don’t have to agree with it. But what’s done is done. This isn’t the political forum. Everyone needs to focus on the bowl match ups and making money. I’m a Kansas fan and I plan on seeing a blow out against a bad UNLV team. A 9 win year is going to look mighty fine going into next season without Texas and Oklahoma.

you have yet to bring any substance to this realm aside from slapping Deezy on the ass with ata boys and they just don’t understands

at this point anyone who refuses to SEE and accept the reason why a travisLESS fsu was left out then there isn’t much hope for you

bol though

I think Ville with all their starters struggled mightily against an FSU team with a third string frosh QB that has never started a game and Noles won by double digits. 2 weeks ago Bama with all of their starters went on the road and struggled mightily with an bad bad Auburn team that lost to a DII school the previous week at home. From your logic, no way Bama should be in either I guess, yet they are. See your bias against FSU shines. You do not hold Bama to the same standard you criticize FSU for. 

I think everyones problem is that injuries or backup Qbs playing on potential playoff teams was never, ever a factor in the 10 years they have been doing the playoff until it was possible that an SEC team would be left out. If that were the case Ohio State would have never gotten in with Cardale Jones, I believe I heard two other examples of this happening with injuries in the playoff era now. Another problem is that the committee has known Jordan Travis has been injured for the last 3 weeks, yet ranked them in the playoff despite this every week of injury until now. If they were never seriously going to put them in because of the injury why have them as high as ranked #4 in any of the last 3 previous weeks? It makes no sense. It has nothing to do with the 4 "best". This is simply a case of not wanting to freeze SEC out of playoff. Plain and simple. 

@DeezyAZ81

 Bama beat Auburn. did they lose? NO.  So now should have lost is a loss? So let me remind u that FSU barely beat BC 31-29 laying -24 points with. Healthy Travis at QB. They should have lost that game as well. 

@DeezyAZ81

 The problem for u is Alabama beat #1 and fucked everything u are talking about regarding fsu being #4 all weeks prior 

U also mentioned best...

Well bama beat the perceived best... so that has to count for something to the committee 

But at the end of the day it all came down to the Travis being out. Which makes sense. Especially when factored in with bama fuckin the rankings

Nope. Just like Noles beat Ville (better than Auburn), Florida (better than Auburn) the last two weeks. That's my point you are holding close wins against FSU but not Alabama. Your logic does not make sense. Bama's win versus a bad Auburn on a last second hail mary on 4th and 31 is luckier than any win Noles have had all season and it happened a week ago.

Noles 31-29 win vs BC was like 3 months ago and FSU let their foot off the gas, the team was legit up 31-10 and just lost interest in the 2nd half and $ucked around. Bama was legitimately losing or tied with $hitty Auburn the entire game last week. Hardly looked like 1 of the 4 "best" a week ago needing a hail mary to beat a 6-5 Auburn that just lost to New Mexico State. Your eye test BS just does not make sense because you are all over the place with your standards. 

No the problem is that Alabama looks rather inconsistent. So one week they need a hail mary to beat a $hit Auburn team that just lost to a DII school at thome and the next week they beat the "perceived" #1 team by 3. That shows a lot of inconsistency, not that the team is a clear cut one of 4 best in country. It is just pure BS. The committee just needs to admit, we are not permitted to leave the SEC out of the playoff. 

If you think Bama deserved to win at Auburn, you are the biggest Homer alive. Might have been as lucky as the kick 6 10 years ago. My point is they did not look dominant in the least against a bad bad Auburn team. 

For the record I also think Bama will beat Michigan and compete for the title. The committee's justification for choosing these teams this morning is simply asinine though. They simply made up criteria, which legit did not exist last week or any of the last 10 years of choosing teams. That is my problem. The playoff rankings are predictor over the last month were legitimately pointless because the only thing that mattered was how conference championship games turned out. They used this injury to Jordan Travis horse$hit to shovel the public $hit. 

Did Florida State lose? Do they have any losses on the season? Your argument holds no weight sir.