I think the NFL should BAN the Punch out move

Bunch of wimps indeed sac but then again we are talking about head Pom Pom cheerleader for the 49ers, ActionMagnet. 

@ActionMagnet

 I agree punching or hitting the  football to cause a fumble should be illegal its BS

Punching a football is not an athletic move; anyone can throw a punch; it has nothing to do with being tough.  Turnovers dramatically impact the game; I would rather see more offense which is what the NFL wants also.  A dramatic 50 yd run through broken tackles and hits can be negated by some dude making a move my cousin could make.

OK Grandpa 

How about they ban tackling altogether? and just play flag football and force the players to wear skirts on the field.

covers need sub-forums for flag football and softball. 

If he punch the football and misses and hit my balls, I'll get mad too

Just kneed down baby. There is no punch at all. 

@undermysac

try that 

@ActionMagnet

 I somewhat agree but get it.  However, if you miss the ball and hit the player it should be an ejection.  The rule would need to be changed as the letter of the law reads throwing a punch at an opponent whereas it's clear they're throwing the punch at the ball.

@ActionMagnet

Guarantee you've never played tackle football on any level before

And whoever liked this guys comment should be ashamed of themselves 

Punching at a football (but hitting the other player on their body) should be just like a pro hockey player going high-stick to stop a flying puck but hitting another player in the face instead. It's not about the intent; it's about the end result.  Just happened in the Eagles/Commanders division championship game. Dude punched at ball, wholly missed the ball, and hit ball-carrier's unprotected forearm. I don't agree with full ejection, but there should definitely be a penalty--one that would have reversed that turnover.

@ScottCameron

Are you serious? A fumble is so rare and it’s one of the most exciting plays in football. Sit down. 

@ActionMagnet

 How about no touching?  It’s a contact sports not yoga 

@BannerJoe7645

 Derrick Henry was a step ahead of you. He removed the hair wear to get faster. 

@ActionMagnet

 I totally agree. I bought this up with a bunch of friends and saying that it should be an illegal move to punch with a clench fist. Because what if you miss and accidentally hit the guy in the throat that should be a personal foul right.   Hope the NFL bring this up in their meetings of new rules. 

@undermysac

 They are probably Gen Z ers

Me thinks they should ban these two as take away from the spirit of football

1 -- When they tackle a guy and he rolls on top of the body of the tackler but doesn't touch the ground.   That is a tackle and should be awarded as such.

2 -- The tush push.  NO ONE should be allowed to push the QB from behind.   He should do it on his own ... mano y mano

Rainbow alert 

Anyone who’s actually played football at any level, even just high school football, knows that punching out the ball is a STANDARD defensive technique for trying to cause a fumble. Whether it’s a fist, open hand, or even a damn slap, don’t matter 

Sorry for your loss 

[Quote: Originally Posted by ActionMagnet]Using a clenched fist to punch at the offensive players hand/wrist area to knock the ball loose Is NOT a legal football move by any stretch of the imagination. It’s one thing if you tackle the running player or QB by wrapping around him and dislodging the ball. Using your fist to directly punch at the player should be freaking illegal imho.[/Quote]

I completely agree.  And It wasn't always part of the game like it is now.  Coaches actually make it a point and teach this stuff. 

Not good.... 

Completely agree, Raiders.... 

A player has to be down to be tackled. He is down when any part of the body other than feet or hands touches the ground.  If they changed that, it would create a ton of problems.