SUPER BOWL TEAMS FROM THE WILD CARD ROUND
Beginning in 1997 is when things took a sudden turn to teams from the wild card round making and winning SB's. There have been 11 teams from the wild card round make the SB in 17 SB's.
Those 11 teams are 10-0-1 ATS in the SB, and with half a brain one could have been a perfect 11-0 ATS as the only team to not cover the closing line, the 99 Titans opened at +7.5 and stayed there for a few days.
8 of the 11 teams won the SB, some as big dogs.
Let's break-down those 11 teams in Power Rating 1 and we can divide them into strong, mediocre and weak teams.
STRONG TEAMS...................
97 Denver +8.51
2000 Ravens +11.94
2005 Steelers +12.49
2010 Packers +11.57
These 4 wild card round teams were right there with the ave no.1 and no.2 seeds that make SB'S, not really surprise teams at all, but very strong teams that for whatever reason could not get the bye.
MEDIOCRE TEAM.........................
2006 Colts +5.84
WEAK TEAMS.......................................
99 Titans +3.32
2003 Panthers +3.49
2007 Giants (-2.12)
2008 Zona +2.3
2011 Giants +3.09
2012 Ravens +2.68
5 of the 8 teams that won the SB rated 5.84 or higher, the 6 teams below 4 were just 3-3 at winning the SB.
Of 46 no. 1 & 2 seeds to make the SB since 1990, just 4 were below 5, those 5 winning teams were right there with past no.1 and no 2 seeds.
That leaves us with 6 weak teams.
Going back to 1978, the first year of the 16 game schedule when the league also changed the rules to open-up the passing game and increase scoring, there have been 7 additional weak teams make the SB, under 4.55, mostly bye teams but does include the very first wild card team to win the SB, 1980 Raiders at +4.55.
Are there any common denominators of these weak teams ?
The media is very powerful at shaping and forming your perception of sports. The first thing a pundit will mention is back the team with a proven winner at QB, many go their entire lives believing this.
HERE'S THE HARD REALITY.....................................
I'll list the teams with the starting QB'S playoff record next to them.
1979 Rams (-1.45), Ferragamo 0-0, never been in a playoff game, yet guided a weak team to the SB.
1980 Raiders +4.55, Plunket, 0-0 considered a bust for the 1st player taken in the draft prior to winning the SB.
83 Raiders +3.87, Plunkett 5-1, SB winner
86 Denver +2.25 , Elway 0-1
96 Chargers, Stan H. 1-1
96 Pats +4.2, Bledsoe 0-1
2001 Pats +3.22 , Brady 0-0
99 Titans +3.22 Mcnair 0-0
2003 Panthers +3.49 Delhomme 0-0
2007 Giants (-2.12) Eli, 0-2 considered a disappointment for the no.1 overall player taken in the draft prior to winning the SB.
2008 Zona +2.3, Warner 5-2 SB winner
2011 Giants +3.09, Eli 4-3 SB winner
2012 Ravens +2.68, Flacco 5-4 some playoff success with 2 AFC championship losses to his credit, but he got there twice.
Of the 13 weak teams to make the SB just 3 were QB'd by a previous SB winning QB, and 4 of 13 by a QB with some playoff success when we add Flacco.
9 of the 13 QB's had no prior playoff success (1-5 record in playoff games) ...................... 5 of the 13 QB'S had never been in a NFL playoff game prior to taking a weak team to the SB.
There have been more QB's who've never played in a playoff game (5) do it then previous SB winning QB's (3).
That folks is the power the media has to shape and form your beliefs, and some of those beliefs you'll carry with you the rest of your life.