Spice Up Your Super Bowl 58 Betting With Cross-Sport Props Bets

Super Bowl prop bets have grown so much that there are now cross-sport props available.

Andrew Caley - Senior Betting Analyst at Covers.com
Andrew Caley • Senior Betting Analyst
Feb 11, 2024 • 13:14 ET • 2 min read
Patrick Mahomes Kansas City Chiefs NFL
Photo By - USA TODAY Sports

As we're presented with literally thousands of options for Super Bowl prop bets for the Big Game, it should come as no surprise that sportsbooks have gotten creative with Big Game props over the years. One of the most fun new Super Bowl odds to wager on is cross-sport props. 

We're no longer limited to betting on player props like who will have more completions between the competing quarterbacks. Now, you can diversify your Super Bowl predictions portfolio with bets crossing over into the NHL, NBA, college basketball, golf... and even international soccer! 

Super Bowl cross-sports prop odds analysis

Mahomes completions vs. Tatum points

Bet Caesars
Mahomes +1.5 completions -115
Tatum -1.5 points vs. Heat -115

Star Kansas City Chiefs quarterback Patrick Mahomes is going to sling it in Super Bowl LVIII. Mahomes averaged 25.1 completions per game this season and 24.8 completions over 17 career playoff games. In this year’s Big Game, his completions prop is set at 25.5, and he now gets to go against a San Francisco 49ers defense that allowed the third-most completions per game in the NFL this season.

Boston Celtics forward Jayson Tatum averages 27 points per game this season. But he has been held to 24 points or fewer six times in his last 11 games. And he gets a tough matchup on Sunday against the Miami Heat. Tatum averages 22.6 points per game in his career vs. the Heat. I like getting the +1.5 with Mahomes here.

Pick: Patrick Mahomes +1.5 completions vs. Jayson Tatum points against Heat (-115 at Caesars)

Mahomes 1st-half passing yards vs. Thunder points

Bet Caesars
Mahomes +1.5 first-half passing yards -115
Thunder team total vs. Kings -115

Let’s go back-to-back with Mahomes/NBA props. It was a “down” year for Mahomes in terms of passing yardage, but a down year for him still means 261.4 passing yards per game. Generally, Mahomes does his best work in the first half, averaging 147.6 passing yards before halftime this season.
 
The Oklahoma City Thunder are a high-scoring team, but if Mahomes gets close to this average in the first half, this bet will be close to a lock. The Thunder average 120.8 points per game and play the Sacramento Kings on Sunday in what should be a competitive game. OKC has put up 123 and 98 points, respectively, in two meetings vs. Sacramento this season. Even if the Thunder got close to 130, Mahomes still looks like the right side.

Pick: Mahomes +1.5 passing yards vs. Thunder team total against Kings (-115 at Caesars)

Best Super Bowl bonuses

FanDuel New Users
Get $200 in bonus bets
If your first bet (min. $5) wins! Claim Now

DraftKings New Users
Get $200 in bonus bets
When your first bet is $5+! Claim Now

BetMGM New Users
Bet $5 on any wager
Get $158 in bonus bets! Claim Now

bet365 All Users
Instant ML bet payout
If your team goes up by 17+! Claim Now

Eligible USA locations only. Also, see our full list of best sportsbook promotions for 2024.
21+. Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER

Kelce receiving yards vs. WM Phoenix Open winner 4th-round score

Bet Caesars
Kelce -4.5 receiving yards -115
WM Phoenix Open winner's 4th-round score +4.5 -115

Travis Kelce’s receiving yards prop is sitting at 71.5. Taylor Swift’s boyfriend has had at least 71 yards receiving in each of his last 12 playoff games. He’s had 81 or more yards nine times over that stretch. If Kelce gets to 81, this bet is in the bag. But hell, if he gets to 71, he’ll still have a chance to cash it.

The winning score in the final round of the WM Phoenix Open each of the last three years has been 65, 67, and 65. If the winner posts a 65 again, Kelce will need just 70 yards to cash this bet.

Pick: Kelce -4.5 receiving yards vs. WM Phoenix Open winner's fourth-round score (-115 at Caesars)

Samuel receptions vs. Scheffler 4th-round birdies or better

Bet Caesars
Samuel total receptions -115
Scheffler 4th-round birdies (or better) -115

Deebo Samuel will arguably be the most dynamic player in a game full of them during Super Bowl LVIII. The San Francisco 49ers use Samuel effectively in both the running and passing games.

But sometimes, he is more heavily used in one facet than the other depending on the game plan, and that can mean fewer catches. Samuel has only hauled in six or more receptions five times this season.

Scottie Scheffler, on the other hand, is a scoring machine. He leads the PGA Tour in birdies or better and is 16th in fourth-round scoring average. In his two wins at the WM Phoenix Open, he’s gone for eight and five birdies or better in the final round. Scottie has the edge in this matchup.

Pick: Scheffler to get more fourth-round birdies or better than Samuel receptions (-115 at Caesars)

Covers Super Bowl betting tools

Purdy TD passes vs. 1P goals between Blues-Canadiens

Bet Caesars
Purdy TD passes -125
Blues-Canadiens total 1P goals -105

The former Mr. Irrelevant sure isn’t going by that moniker anymore. Brock Purdy is more than the 49ers could have ever dreamed of. The former final pick of the 2022 NFL Draft is coming off a fantastic sophomore season where he threw 31 touchdown passes.

Meanwhile, scoring could be light on the ice in the first period between the St. Louis Blues and Montreal Canadiens on Sunday afternoon. The Habs have scored the third-fewest first-period goals in the NHL this season while giving up the ninth-fewest. Meanwhile, the Blues rank a paltry 17th in first-period scoring.

You’re looking for Purdy to throw two touchdown passes to win this bet. But he might still be able to cash it throwing one.

Pick: Purdy to throw more TD passes than first-period goals scored in Blues vs. Canadiens (-125 at Caesars)

More Super Bowl cross-sports prop odds

FanDuel Odds
Either Patrick Mahomes to win Super Bowl MVP OR Scottie Scheffler to win Phoenix Open -145
Either Travis Kelce to score first TD OR Shai Gilgeous-Alexander (vs. Kings 11th of February) to score first basket +145
Either Christian McCaffrey to score first TD OR Scottie Scheffler to win Phoenix Open +150
Either Christian McCaffrey to score first TD OR Jayson Tatum (vs. Heat 11th of February) to score first basket +150
Either Christian McCaffrey to score first TD OR Cole Caufield (vs. Capitals 11th of February) to score first goal +210
Either Travis Kelce to score first TD OR Scottie Scheffler to win Phoenix Open +220
Either Travis Kelce to score first TD OR De'Aaron Fox (vs. Thunder 11th of February) to score first basket +370
Either Travis Kelce to score first TD OR Brock Boeser (vs. Capitals 11th of February) to score first goal +390
Either George Kittle to score first TD OR Jimmy Butler (vs. Celtics 11th of February) to score first basket +400
Either Travis Kelce to win Super Bowl MVP OR Jordan Spieth to win Phoenix Open +600
Either Travis Kelce to win Super Bowl MVP OR Rickie Fowler to win Phoenix Open +1,000
Travis Kelce to score first TD & Shai Gilgeous-Alexander (vs. Kings 11th of February) to score 35+ points +1,600
Either Kyle Juszczyk to score first TD OR Rickie Fowler to win Phoenix Open +1,600
Brock Purdy to win Super Bowl MVP, Scottie Scheffler to win Phoenix Open & Arsenal to win vs West Ham +1,800
Patrick Mahomes to win Super Bowl MVP, Jordan Spieth to win Phoenix Open & Man United to win vs Aston Villa +3,100
Isiah Pacheco to score first TD & Kristaps Porzingis (vs. Heat 11th of February) to score first basket +3,300

                                                                              DraftKings Odds
Either Scottie Scheffler to win Phoenix Open OR Chiefs to win Super Bowl LVIII -140
Either Christian McCaffrey to score first TD OR Christian Pulisic to score the first goal vs. Napoli +230
Either Travis Kelce to score 2+ TDs OR Christian Pulisic to score 2+ goals +450
Either Christian McCaffery to score 3+ TDs OR Robert Lewandowski to score 3+ Goals vs. Granada +550
Brock Purdy to have 300+ passing yards & Christian Pulisic to score 1+ goals vs. Napoli +1,400
Rashee Rice to have 10+ receptions & Bukayo Saka to score 1+ goals vs. West Ham +1,600
Patrick Mahomes to throw 4+ TDs & Christian Pulisic to score 1+ goals vs. Napoli +3,000
Christian McCaffrey 150+ rush & rec yards & Marcus Rashford to score 2+ goals vs. Aston Villa +3,500

Mahomes passing attempts vs. SGA points and rebounds on Feb. 11

Bet Caesars
Mahomes +0.5 attempts -115
Gilgeous-Alexander -0.5 points and rebounds vs. Kings -115

McCaffrey receiving yards vs. Curry PRA on Feb. 10

Bet Caesars
McCaffrey +3.5 receiving yards -115
Curry -3.5 points, rebounds, and assists vs. Suns -115

Kelce targets vs. Doncic assists on Feb. 10

Bet Caesars
Kelce -0.5 targets -115
Doncic +0.5 assists vs. Thunder -115

Rice longest reception vs. Herro points on Feb. 11

Bet Caesars
Rashee Rice longest reception -155
Tyler Herro points vs. Celtics +125

Chiefs 1st half points vs. Total NHL goals scored on Feb. 11

Bet Caesars
Chiefs 1st half points +0.5 -110
Total NHL goals scored on Sunday -0.5 -120

Where can I bet on Super Bowl cross-sport props?

As we get closer to kickoff for the Big Game, more sportsbooks will offer various cross-sport props — but some offer more props and better odds than others. Head over to our best-suggested sportsbooks to find the top Super Bowl betting sites in your area.

Google News
Stay updated with the latest picks, odds, and news! Tap the star to add us to your favorites on Google News to never miss a story.

Super Bowl cross-sport prop bets FAQs

Pages related to this topic

Senior Betting Analyst

When his dreams of becoming the next Steve Nash died, all Andrew “Taco” Caley wanted to do was write about sports, something he’s been doing at Covers for more than a decade. A Journalism School grad from Holland College in Charlottetown, PEI, Andrew previously worked at The Chronicle Herald and Star Metro, but knew in his heart that his future lay in sports. He began at Covers as a news editor and has now done everything under the sun when it comes to content. His work has been seen on TSN, Sportsnet, VSiN, and CBS.

These days Andrew’s betting expertise is focused on his favorite teams – the Toronto Blue Jays and Toronto Raptors. He’s also an avid college football fan and bettor. He can’t be friends with you if you don’t appreciate a Service Academy Under. You can also call him Covers’ Sixth Man, as he regularly steps up to guest host Before You Bet and our MLB and NCAAF release shows.

The sportsbook where he does the bulk of his betting is bet365 thanks to its numerous prop betting options and competitive odds. His best advice? Find the balance between the numbers and what you see on the playing field. Then find the best price using multiple books. And don’t ask him where the nickname Taco comes from. It’s not an interesting story. Seriously.

Popular Content

Legal Canadian sports betting

Best Canadian betting sites Ontario sports betting
Covers is verified safe by: Evalon Logo GPWA Logo GDPR Logo GeoTrust Logo Evalon Logo