MLB Home Run Props, Picks & Odds Today for 4-20: Paul is Golden

Phil Naessens serves up three of his favorite home run hitters in today's MLB player props slate, including Paul Goldschmidt.

Phil Naessens - Betting Analyst at Covers.com
Phil Naessens • Betting Analyst
Apr 20, 2025 • 09:55 ET • 4 min read
Paul Goldschmidt New York Yankees MLB
Photo By - Imagn Images. Paul Goldschmidt rounds the bases.

Today’s massive slate features numerous players with solid chances of going yard.

I’ve scoured through the matchups and found three hitters in good situations against starting pitchers known to serve one up. 

Read on as I share my MLB player props for Sunday, April 20. 

Best MLB home run props today

HR picks for April 20

Triston Casas (+400 at Caesars)

Triston Casas hit a single off the Monster in the bottom of the tenth inning to lift the Red Sox to a Saturday afternoon victory over the Chicago White Sox.

Maybe Casas' big hit will get him going, because he’s riding the struggle bus. The Boston 1B is batting .176 with one jack across 68 at-bats, but he has a good matchup today against White Sox righty Sean Burke.

Burke has already served up five bombs across 72 batters faced. His fastball and slider are getting swatted all over the yard, and lefty bats have cracked two of those five home runs.

Casas has hit 21 of his 43 career home runs against righties and 16 dingers against right-handed arms at Fenway Park. 

With the wind blowing out to right field, I like his chances of going yard against Burke today. 

Paul Goldschmidt (+400 at Caesars)

The wind is blowing out to right field at George M. Steinbrenner Field, and I like Paul Goldschmidt’s chances of going yard today.

Goldschmidt has been on a tear; the veteran first baseman has hit safely in four straight, and while he has the second most hits on the team (29), he’s only hit one bomb this season.

That could change today as he and the rest of the New York Yankees have a tasty matchup with righty Ryan Pepiot.

Right-handed lumber is smacking Pepiot around the yard. He’s allowed four of his six home runs to righties, and the right side boasts a robust .353 BABIP and .482 wOBA against the righty.

Goldschmidt’s underlying metrics are solid; his .438 BABIP suggests he’s been unlucky, but he bats cleanup in a potent lineup, and if he gets one up in the air, he has a good chance of going yard today. 

Aaron Judge (+400 at Caesars)

Wind blowing out or not, Aaron Judge must be licking his chops at the prospect of batting against Pepiot.

Pepiot is serving up nearly a bomb every nine ABs. His fastball and slider are getting buried deep into the seats, and he’s up against one of the most prolific power hitters in the game.

Judge began the season like a house on fire but has only one homer across the past 49 ABs. His .453 BABIP and 250 wRC+ suggest he’s been unlucky, and Pepiot has been known to serve one up.

Pepiot has served up five taters across the last 16 frames. I like an “unlucky” Judge to get more than lucky with at least one dinger today. 

Not intended for use in MA.
Affiliate Disclosure: Our team of experts has thoroughly researched and handpicked each product that appears on our website. We may receive compensation if you sign up through our links.

Pages related to this topic

Phil Naessens
Betting Analyst

Prior to joining Covers in 2022, Phil Naessens spent 38 years as a resident tennis pro in Las Vegas, Mykonos, and Corfu Greece. He’s the past host of the Phil Naessens Show (Armed Forces Radio), and currently hosts the tennis betting podcast, This Week in Tennis.

Phil is the author of the Betting 101 series (MLB, NFL, NCAAF, and Tennis) and has written for numerous publications including SB Nation, FanSided and Lenny Melnick Fantasy Sports. Phil curates the Chip and Charge Tennis Newsletter and pens a weekly tennis column called “10 Things About the ATP Tour," for Passing Shot Productions. 

His favorite sports to bet on are tennis, MLB, WNBA, Euro men’s and women’s hoops, NCAA sports, NFL, and the NBA. Phil has numerous betting accounts in the US and Europe and his best advice is to line shop for the best value possible.

Popular Content

Covers is verified safe by: Evalon Logo GPWA Logo GDPR Logo GeoTrust Logo Evalon Logo